III.C.2.a. Process Description
Goals, Framework, and Methodology
Title V requires a comprehensive needs assessment every five years to identify the strengths and needs of the MCH population and to guide efforts to improve the health of the MCH population. Michigan’s goals for the 2020 needs assessment were to:
- Use multiple types of data to understand health outcomes, health behaviors, and health disparities, as well as underlying causes that drive inequity;
- Strengthen partnerships and strategies for achieving health equity;
- Engage diverse populations and system partners in describing and understanding the needs and strengths of the MCH population;
- Identify the state priority needs and performance measures that will be the focus of Title V for FY 2021-2025; and
- Identify opportunities to address needs beyond the scope of Title V.
The Public Health Planning Cycle (see Figure 1) from the Title V Guidance was adapted and used to organize the assessment process. Many methods and tools were adapted from the Mobilizing for Action Through Planning and Partnerships (MAPP) framework developed by the National Association of County and City Health Officials (NACCHO). Details on the MAPP assessments as well as findings across population domains are included in the needs assessment report, which is included as a Supporting Document.
Figure 1. Needs Assessment Process
MAPP is a health assessment and improvement planning framework commonly used by local health departments. It was selected to guide the needs assessment because it aligned well with Michigan’s goals. The MAPP process uses multiple types of data, engages diverse system partners, and emphasizes health equity. The framework is comprised of six phases and four assessments, as depicted in Figure 2.
Figure 2. MAPP Phases
Stakeholder Involvement
The needs assessment process was led by Michigan’s Title V MCH and CSCHN directors. Several groups were involved in different aspects of the process to comprehensively represent the Title V population domains, including many MCH stakeholders external to MDHHS and MCH leadership within MDHHS.
- Needs Assessment Planning Committee: Comprised of MDHHS Title V leadership, MDHHS epidemiologists, and MPHI consultants who were responsible for planning and implementation of the needs assessment. The group convened in May 2018 to begin the planning process and oversaw all logistics.
- Title V Steering Committee: Comprised of state MCH staff who oversee programs and initiatives that receive Title V funding and/or implement Title V state action plans. Members provided feedback and insight into the needs assessment process and used findings to inform state action plans.
- Needs Assessment Stakeholder Group: Included more than 70 MCH stakeholders from across Michigan, with over 50% representation outside of MDHHS. This group convened from February 2019 to February 2020 and participated in several needs assessment activities.
- Population Domain Workgroups: Three workgroups were convened to reflect the Title V population domains: women/maternal health and perinatal/infant health; child/adolescent health; and CSHCN. Participants at each workgroup included state and local MCH staff, MCH system partners, consumers and parent representatives, and partners with health equity expertise. The workgroups identified needs within each population domain based on the needs assessment findings and their experience within the MCH system.
Organizations and program areas that participated in the above groups are listed in a Supporting Document. Notably, the needs assessment was completed prior to the COVID-19 pandemic. The Title V program recognizes the significant impacts of COVID-19 on the MCH population and will assess emerging and shifting MCH needs over the next year.
Quantitative and Qualitative Methods and Data Sources
Identification of unmet needs was based on the four MAPP assessments, described below. The assessments collected a combination of qualitative and quantitative data to provide a holistic view of health and were tailored to focus on the MCH population.
Health Status Assessment
This assessment uses quantitative population level data to describe health status. The assessment began by identifying key MCH health indicators, including Title V National Performance Measures and National Outcome Measures and other measures tracked in each population domain.
Seventy health indicators were identified for maternal and infant health, of which 60 had adequate data for analysis. Eighty-two indicators were identified for child and adolescent health, of which 59 had adequate data for analysis. To identify indicators suggesting need, the following criteria were applied to each measure: a Black/White disparity of 10% or more; observed Black/White disparities worsening over time (minimum five years of data); statewide trend worsening over time (minimum five years of data); and Michigan performing two percentage points worse than the US overall in the most recent data year.
The analysis of CSHCN data relied heavily on the National Survey of Children’s Health (2016-2017 combined) and used the HRSA Maternal Child Health Bureau (MCHB) framework for understanding the prevalence and impact of special health care needs on children. Key indicators quantified the types and levels of severity of special health care needs for children in Michigan. Selected indicators were stratified by CYSHCN status and level of complexity, at both the state and national level. Analysis focused on understanding the CSHCN population as compared to all children and those without special health care needs. When possible, data were stratified by race and ethnicity.
System Assessment
This assessment explores the degree to which public health systems deliver essential services within existing capacity and available resources. Michigan focused on six of the 10 essential public health services: educate and empower; mobilize partnerships; develop policies; link to/provide health services; evaluate and improve; and inform and apply research. These services were prioritized to gather input from external partners to develop a well-rounded view of capacity. The National Public Health Performance Standards Program, which is designed to be inclusive of all public health services, was used to complete the assessment. The tool was significantly adapted for Michigan’s needs assessment to focus on MCH and health equity.
The system assessment was completed during a facilitated full-day meeting of the Stakeholder Group and involved a series of discussion questions to identify strengths and gaps in capacity in each essential service. After discussing specific aspects of an essential service, the group used confidential electronic voting to capture the degree to which the system was delivering the service.
Forces of Change Assessment
This assessment identifies forces outside the MCH system that could impact population health. Forces include trends, factors, and events that may influence health, both in the recent past and the foreseeable future. This assessment was completed by members of the Stakeholder Group who self-selected into one of four breakout groups: women, maternal and infant; child and adolescent; CSHCN; or cross-cutting. The assessment was completed during a half-day facilitated session in which each group identified forces that influence health. Forces that could create inequities were highlighted.
Community Themes and Strengths Assessment
This assessment gathers the perspectives of community members, including thoughts, experiences, and opinions about their health and quality of life. It is designed to gain a deeper understanding of the strengths, assets, and barriers that exist in communities. Data for this assessment were collected through provider surveys, encounter surveys, focus groups, and listening sessions with both service providers and community members across Title V population domains. The provider survey was an online survey administered to participants (n=526) through the survey platform Qualtrics. The encounter survey was administered to recipients of MCH services (n=307) in one of two formats, an online survey or paper survey. Trained facilitators facilitated 18 focus groups and listening sessions to gather experiences and perspectives on health. Quantitative survey data were analyzed in SPSS and qualitative data were thematically analyzed to identify reoccurring strengths, barriers, and opportunities for improvement.
Identifying Priority Needs
After completion of the four MAPP assessments, data were analyzed to identify themes. Themes were identified when common topics or issues arose across each MAPP assessment. This filter supported narrowing themes, and ultimately priorities, to those most present in the data. The only exception to this process was related to the Community Themes and Strengths Assessment findings. If community data led to a theme that was less present in the other assessments, it was still included as a theme.
Three population domain workgroups representing a broad array of MCH stakeholders were convened in the fall of 2019 to review the findings of the MAPP assessments, review the themes, and identify priority needs. This process involved three full-day meetings. During the morning session, participants were guided through the assessment findings. In the afternoon, they participated in a facilitated session to explore each of the themes and draft priority need statements.
Following the population domain workgroups, over 50 priority need statements were reviewed to identify areas of commonality. Where the groups identified a similar need, a consolidated need statement was developed. Those needs that best aligned with Title V were identified and linked to a relevant NPM or SPM. The needs assessment findings were then used to inform state action plan development. Originally, an in-person workshop was planned with MCH staff to develop strategies, objectives, and ESMs. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the meeting was shifted to a webinar format during which guidance and resources for developing state action plans were provided. State action plans were developed with virtual technical assistance from Title V staff.
II.C.2.b Findings
III.C.2.b.i MCH Population Health Status
Michigan’s Title V priority needs for 2021-2025 were developed from themes that emerged across the four MAPP assessments. This section provides a high-level summary of major findings from each assessment, highlighting data that drove the selection of priority needs and performance measures.
Strengths and Needs
The Community Themes and Strengths Assessment revealed assets and needs across each population domain. The themes most closely related to Michigan’s Title V priority needs are summarized here.
Women, Maternal, & Infant Health
The provider survey, focus groups, and encounter survey all identified barriers in accessing healthcare, specialty providers, and mental healthcare for women and mothers. Provider survey and focus group participants shared that the cost of medical care limits access; families experience gaps in coverage; and coverage is too limited. Additionally, encounter survey and focus group participants identified gaps in the availability of high-quality care, including prenatal care, postnatal care, breastfeeding education and support, and family planning.
Provider burnout and a lack of birthing hospital access in rural areas was highlighted as a gap by both consumers and providers. The provider survey identified provider shortages in areas of the workforce critical to the health of women and mothers, including licensed medical social workers, community health workers, obstetricians, gynecologists, and medical assistants.
Women and mothers who participated in focus groups reported experiences of racism and implicit bias when seeking medical care. Focus group participants also reported feeling their race impacted the quality of care they received, particularly around family planning and birth spacing. This finding was echoed in responses to the provider survey, where providers suggested that frontline medical providers could benefit from training in implicit bias.
Focus group participants reported that more support for infant safe sleep and positive parenting practices would help families. Similarly, provider survey respondents suggested expanding supportive services such as home visiting, early childhood programs, and Great Start Collaboratives to support family planning, safe sleep, breastfeeding, and parenting. Focus group participants provided examples of restrictive workforce policies and practices that limit breastfeeding and stressed the need for supportive breastfeeding policies.
Child & Adolescent Health
Mistrust in the healthcare system was reported as a concern among focus group participants who noted gaps in access to accurate, trusted, linguistically appropriate, and culturally adapted messages about child health. Additionally, focus group participants reported that healthcare could be more accessible if it were integrated into settings where children live, learn, and play, such as school-based health centers. The provider survey also raised concerns about the availability of primary care for young children and limited access to preventive services.
Focus group and encounter survey participants reported environmental health concerns such as lead and PFAS contamination. They noted that socioeconomic status and race drive inequities in childhood exposure to lead contamination. Housing stock free of environmental contaminants was identified as a challenge, especially in lower-income neighborhoods. Focus group participants noted the need for greater investment in safe, livable communities and quality housing. This concern was echoed in the provider survey, and providers also noted that structural racism impacts exposure to unsafe living conditions.
Bullying, child abuse, domestic violence, and social/emotional abuse were all raised as concerns facing children and adolescents. Bullying in schools was highlighted as driving risky behaviors and mental health challenges among children and adolescents, especially those who identify as LGBTQ+. Focus group participants shared that schools need additional support to address the social and emotional needs of students, such as more counselors, social workers, and nurses.
Children with Special Health Care Needs
Insurance challenges and gaps in specialty providers were identified through focus groups and encounter surveys as challenges for families with CSHCN. Participants noted that access to available therapies, adaptive devices, and payment options that cover a variety of needs would help alleviate some of the stressors that result from caring for a child with special needs. Additionally, silos in communication across providers and provider turnover were reported as challenges that contribute to challenges in transition to adult care.
Multiple Population Domains
Mental and behavioral health was identified as an area of concern across population domains and through each data collection method. An overall lack of mental and behavioral health providers in Michigan, especially in rural areas, was reported as a challenge. Specifically, substance use disorder treatment and access to Community Mental Health centers were highlighted as challenges by focus group participants. Focus group participants also described how stigma surrounding mental health contributes to generational mental health issues and challenges.
While the Community Themes and Strengths Assessment highlighted many needs across population domains, it also identified assets such as:
- Michigan’s caring and compassionate providers offer high-quality care with limited resources;
- Federally Qualified Health Centers, local health departments, and school-based health centers fill gaps in access to care;
- Community-based, culturally and linguistically appropriate organizations provide quality support services;
- A strong home visiting system that spans the state and provides numerous programming options to align with family needs;
- Michigan’s CSHCS program and its long-standing history of providing quality supports and helping families afford care; and
- Longstanding relationships, collaborative bodies, and MCH expertise at the state and local level.
Major Health Findings
The Health Status Assessment elevated strengths and areas of concern in each Title V population domain. Key findings related to Title V priority needs are highlighted below.
Women, Maternal, & Infant Health
Addressing disparities in infant and maternal mortality is one of Michigan’s top MCH priorities. Michigan has a large and persistent disparity between white and black women in maternal mortality, and the maternal mortality rate in Michigan overall has been increasing since 2012 to a high of 82/100,000 live births in 2016 (Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance, MDHHS, 2011-2016). Additionally, black infants are three times more likely to die before their first birthday as compared to white infants (14.6/1,000 as compared with 4.8/1,000 live births in 2017) (Vital Records & Health Statistics, MDHHS). Disparities also exist within other racial and ethnic groups.
The assessment highlighted factors driving maternal and infant health outcomes. Michigan has persistently lagged the US in women receiving prenatal care beginning in the first trimester (72.4% US compared to 64.0% MI in 2017), and black women in Michigan are 20% less likely to begin care in the first trimester (Vital Records & Health Statistics, MDHHS). Similarly, Michigan’s mothers undergo a low-risk cesarean delivery more frequently than the US (26.0% in the US compared to 28.7% in MI in 2017), and both the disparity and the rate for black mothers are increasing (Vital Records & Health Statistics, MDHHS, 2012-2017). Disparities in safe sleep are also striking; babies who are black are 20% less likely to be placed on their backs to sleep as compared to babies who are white (MI PRAMS, 2012-2017). Babies who are black are also 40% less likely than babies who are white to sleep alone, in a safe bed, on their backs (MI PRAMS, 2012-2017). Finally, while Michigan has seen a steady increase in breastfeeding initiation, disparities remain with 77.2% of black mothers initiating breastfeeding as compared to 90.1% of white mothers in 2017 (MI PRAMS, 2012-2017).
The assessment also highlighted improvements in the health of women, mothers, and infants. Since 2012, Michigan has observed a steady increase in women receiving a routine medical checkup in the past 12 months, from 62.9% in 2012 to 69.1% in 2017 (Behavioral Risk Factory Surveillance Survey). Smoking during pregnancy has also declined from 16.5% in 2012 to 11.3% in 2017 (MI PRAMS).
Child & Adolescent Health
One strategy to support child and adolescent health is through access to a medical home. The assessment found a disparity between white and black children, with 53.3% of white children having a medical home compared to 29.0% of black children in 2017-2018 (National Survey of Children’s Health, 2016-2018). Similarly, Michigan found disparities in access to preventive dental visits, with black children (71.5%) being less likely than white children (79.2%) to receive a preventive dental visit (NSCH, 2016-2018). Michigan also lags in vaccination rates. Children in Michigan ages 19-35 months have been less likely than children in the US to complete the seven-vaccine series every year from 2013 and 2017, and only 69.9% completed the series in 2017 (National Immunization Surveys). Children in Michigan’s large, urban centers have significantly higher rates of elevated blood lead levels among children under age six as compared with the state. For example, in 2016, 8.8% of children under six years old who received testing in Detroit had a blood lead level greater than or equal to 5 micrograms of lead per deciliter of blood, as compared with 3.6% in Michigan (Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program, MDHHS). Finally, rates of bullying in Michigan have remained high with 29.6% of high school students reporting bullying in the past 12 months in 2017. Rates of bullying are higher among American Indian high school students, 43.6% of whom reported bullying in 2017 (Youth Risk Behavior Surveillance System, 2011-2017).
However, Michigan experienced improvements in continuous and adequate insurance for children. The percentage of children 0-17 without health insurance declined each year from 2012 to 2017; Michigan’s children were less likely to be without health insurance as compared to the US; and black children were less likely to be uninsured than white children (NSCH, 2016-2018). Additionally, Michigan observed a steady decline in its teen birth rate among females age 15-19, from 26.2/1,000 in 2012 to 15.8/1,000 in 2018 (Vital Records & Health Statistics, MDHHS, 2012-2018).
Children with Special Health Care Needs
The CSHCN data revealed unique needs among this population. The assessment raised concerns regarding adequacy and continuity of insurance coverage with 36.4% of CSHCN reporting that their insurance was inadequate or that they encountered a gap in coverage (NSCH, 2016-17). Additionally, 46.1% of CSHCN (as compared with 38.3% CSHCN in the US) experienced bullying (2016-17) (NSCH, 2016-17). Finally, only 16.0% of CSHCN had the support needed to transition to adult care, which was lower than the US average of 16.7% (NSCH, 2016-17).
Multiple Population Domains
The Health Status Assessment identified findings across population domains related to mental health. In 2017, 19.2% of Michigan women 18-44 reported more than 14 days of poor mental health in the past 30 days, as compared to 16.2% in the US. Moreover, 24.2% of black women reported poor mental health (BRFS). Similarly, the prevalence of postpartum depression for black women was reported to be almost twice that of white women in 2018 (23.6% compared to 13.6%) (MI PRAMS). Among adolescents, 37.3% reported feeling sad or hopeless for two weeks or more in 2017, a dramatic increase from the 26.0% who reported feeling sad or hopeless in 2011 (YRBS, 2011-2017). Michigan has also seen a disturbing upward trend in suicide mortality among adolescents from 6.5/100,000 in 2012 to 7.5/100,000 in 2016 (Vital Records & Health Statistics, MDHHS, 2013-2017). Finally, access to mental health care is problematic across all population groups, including CSHCN. Compared with a US average of 22.9%, 27.4% of CSCHN in Michigan sometimes or never had the insurance coverage they need for mental/behavioral care (2016-17) (NSCH, 2016-17).
MCH Efforts to Address Needs
The System Capacity Assessment identified strengths and weaknesses of the MCH system in Michigan. The Forces of Change Assessment identified opportunities and threats in the broader sociocultural and political context. Although the System Capacity Assessment was organized by Essential Services and not by population domain, this summary of key findings is organized by population domain for continuity.
Women, Maternal, & Infant Health
The System Assessment identified examples of services and strategies helping to meet the needs of this population. Michigan’s Regional Perinatal Quality Collaboratives are enhancing collaboration and supporting innovation; home visiting models are supporting families throughout pregnancy, birth, and the early years; safe sleep partners have developed and disseminated more culturally sensitive and responsive messaging for families; and policy and programs that support breastfeeding have grown steadily.
However, the System Assessment raised concerns regarding the shortage of OB/GYNs, nurse midwives, doulas and other specialty providers, especially in the state’s rural areas. These provider shortages limit supports available for women and mothers around breastfeeding, safe sleep, and family planning. The System Assessment also raised concern about the availability of birthing hospitals.
The Forces of Change Assessment noted factors beyond the MCH system that impact the health of women, mothers, and infants. The assessment highlighted the impact of the political climate on women’s health and raised concerns about access to family planning and unbiased reproductive care. The assessment also noted that existing policies and polarization create barriers to promoting optimal health and well-being for women and mothers. Medicaid work requirements, for example, were generating significant concerns about access to care. Finally, the assessment described how racism, discrimination, and biases in society have significant impacts on the health and well-being of women of color.
Child & Adolescent Health
The System Assessment identified examples of services that benefit children and adolescents. Home visiting and early childhood system building efforts have worked toward providing greater continuity and connection across services for young children. Additionally, while they are not available statewide, school-based health centers were noted as a key asset in Michigan’s public schools.
The System Assessment found gaps in the capacity of the MCH system to provide preventive services in the places where families live, learn, work, and play. This included primary care, dental care, developmental services, and mental health services. It also found gaps in the availability of home visiting beyond the first year; gaps in health and mental health care within school settings; and gaps in collaboration between different types of providers. The assessment noted that MCH services are often siloed, although examples of collaboration and coordination exist.
The Forces of Change Assessment indicated that the consistently rising cost of medical school was compounding the shortage of primary care providers. In addition, the assessment found that funding cuts to public education have led to a decrease in school nurses, threatening access to care. The assessment also raised concern about trauma and Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) threatening the mental and physical health of children and adolescents. Finally, the assessment highlighted the complex and multifaceted impact of technology on child and adolescent health (which can be both positive and negative) and the need to address cyber bullying.
Children with Special Health Care Needs
The System Assessment noted several strengths of the CSHCN system in Michigan. Most prominently, the Family Center for CYSHCN was highlighted as a system strength. The Family Center provides support, information, and linkages to families of children with special health care needs and elevates the voices of parents within the system.
The System Assessment also highlighted the complexity of providing services and supports to CSHCN given that coordinating services for this population requires collaboration across multiple agencies and systems. Silos in communication and connectivity among partners present barriers to providing coordinated care and create barriers for families in accessing supports. The System Assessment also noted unique system gaps faced by this population and emphasized the potential for telemedicine and telehealth to mitigate some challenges.
The uncertainty of the health insurance system was reported as a challenge throughout the Forces of Change Assessment, specifically for individuals with pre-existing conditions. The supports that are provided through CSHCS, coordinated care and adequate transition services were identified as potential ways to support CSHCN and minimize the risk of losing adequate care.
Multiple Population Domains
Across all population domains, the System Assessment found that the MCH system has made progress toward improving its focus on equity. However, the assessment also found that more work is needed to address the root causes of inequity. The assessment highlighted the lack of diversity in the MCH workforce; the need to use data in more innovative ways to identify and address inequities; and the need for additional education for MCH providers on implicit bias. The System Assessment also noted the need for better linkages between healthcare services and community-based services to address social determinants of health and link families to needed services.
The System Assessment noted significant limitations on the provision of mental and behavioral healthcare and developmental services across all population domains. It found a systemic lack of consistent resources supporting access to these services, creating barriers to ensuring Michiganders have continued access to needed care.
Finally, the Forces of Change Assessment identified concerns about the rising cost of healthcare and other basic needs which may force families to make difficult choices between food or medicine, healthcare or rent. The assessment also highlighted the impact that a lack of a basic living wage can have on health, and the disproportionate increase in the cost of living versus access to jobs that pay a living wage.
III.C.2.b.ii. Title V Program Capacity
III.C.2.b.ii.a. Organizational Structure
The Title V program is administered by the Division of Maternal and Infant Health (DMIH) within MDHHS. The Division Director is the Title V MCH Director. The Division is located within the Bureau of Health and Wellness which includes the Divisions of Chronic Disease and Injury Control; Child and Adolescent Health (CAH); Women, Infants and Children (WIC); and Local Health Services. The Bureau of Health and Wellness is located within the Public Health Administration. Structurally, the Title V MCH Director reports to the Director of the Bureau of Health and Wellness, who currently reports to the Chief Deputy for Health. The Chief Deputy for Health is also the Chief Medical Executive and reports directly to the Governor.
The Title V CSHCN program is operated by the Children’s Special Health Care Services (CSHCS) Division. The Division Director is the Title V CSHCN Director. The CSHCS Division is located within the Bureau of Medicaid Care Management and Customer Service which is located within the Medical Services Administration (MSA). The Title V CSHCN Director reports to the Bureau Director, who reports to the MSA Director, who reports to the MDHHS Director.
In Michigan, Title V funding is used to support programs and services across several bureaus and administrations. A Title V leadership team (including DMIH, DCAH, and CSHCS directors) provides administrative oversight for Title V in coordination with program areas that receive Title V funding. Title V allotments currently support the following:
- Local Health Departments
- Medical Care and Treatment for CSHCN
- Family Planning Local Agreements
- Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program
- Immunizations
- Dental Programs for Children
- Infant Safe Sleep
- Family Center for CYSHCN
- MCH special projects including maternal mortality surveillance, PRAMS, fetal alcohol spectrum disorder, and parent leadership
The mechanisms by which MDHHS administers Title V are described throughout the grant.
III.C.2.b.ii.b. Agency Capacity
MDHHS has a longstanding history and capacity to promote and protect the health of the MCH population, including CSHCN. Most Title V programs are administered by the DMIH, DCAH, and CSHCS. Collectively, these three divisions provide services across the five HRSA population domains. They also work with MCH programs outside their divisions that receive Title V funding (e.g., Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program, Immunizations, and maternal and infant mortality surveillance) to ensure a statewide system of services with comprehensive, community-based care. The divisions are responsible for assessing need; recommending policy; developing and promoting best practices and service models; engaging families and communities; and supporting the capacity within communities to provide high quality, accessible, culturally competent services. Priority is placed on prevention and health promotion activities to improve physical and behavioral health. A synopsis of key program areas is below.
Division of Maternal and Infant Health: DMIH focuses on improving the health, well-being, and quality of life for infants, pregnant women, and women of childbearing age and their families. Major programs include Title X Family Planning, the Maternal Infant Health Program, Infant Safe Sleep, Early Hearing Detection and Intervention (EHDI), Michigan Fetal Infant Mortality Review, Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders, and Regional Perinatal Quality Collaboratives. DMIH provides a leadership role in state efforts to reduce maternal and infant mortality, including oversight of the Mother Infant Health and Equity Improvement Plan. The division provides technical assistance, infrastructure and epidemiologic support across maternal and infant health.
The Women and Maternal Health Section focuses on preconception, interconception, maternal and perinatal health for women. The section supports health planning and the delivery of equitable, quality contraceptive and reproductive health services. The Title X program supports local providers who provide health education and counseling, reproductive health assessments, contraceptive services, and referrals to the general population, including low-income women and men. The section is also involved in statewide breastfeeding and prenatal smoking cessation initiatives.
The Perinatal and Infant Health Section focuses on supporting a healthy perinatal period through positive pregnancy and infant health outcomes. The target populations are pregnant and postpartum women and newborns. The section administers the Maternal Infant Health Program (MIHP), Michigan’s statewide home visiting program for Medicaid beneficiaries. Certified local providers offer assessment, case management and support services to pregnant women and infants. The section is also responsible for infant health initiatives to reduce fetal and infant deaths; achieve infants safe sleep; promote screening and evidence-based treatment for chronic conditions in newborns; and increase the proportion of newborns that receive hearing screens, evaluations and services.
Division of Child and Adolescent Health (DCAH): DCAH works to improve the health and well-being of Michigan’s children, adolescents and young adults. The division is responsible for managing the Local Maternal Child Health (LMCH) program which provides consultation and monitoring to Michigan’s 45 local health departments (LHDs) that receive Title V funding. The Oral Health Unit is also located in DCAH.
The Child and Adolescent School Health Section oversees federal teen pregnancy prevention programs including the Personal Responsibility & Education Program (PREP), the State Abstinence Education Program, and Pregnancy Assistance Funds used to implement the Michigan Adolescent Pregnancy and Parenting Program. These programs work collaboratively with state and local partners including the Michigan Department of Education (MDE), faith-based and health organizations, schools, LHDs, parents, and early childhood partners. The section oversees Michigan’s Child and Adolescent Health Centers (CAHCs), funding 100 health centers and related programs in medically underserved, high-need communities. CAHCs provide primary care and behavioral health services, health education, Medicaid outreach and enrollment, and screening to K-12 students and young adults up to age 21. The section also oversees the state’s school nurse program and mental health in schools initiative; Michigan Model for Health, the state’s comprehensive school health education program; and Hearing & Vision Screening Program.
The Early Childhood Health Section administers programs and initiatives to improve child health outcomes and support the development of an integrated and comprehensive early childhood system, including program management for home visiting and early childhood initiatives. The section administers the MIECHV grant and state home visiting dollars with a focus on stakeholder engagement to build a more effective and robust system. The section oversees the Parent Leadership in State Government initiative and serves as a liaison between public health and Part C/Early On.
CSHCS Division: The CSHCS Division focuses on identifying and addressing the health needs of CSHCN to help them achieve optimal health and an improved quality of life. CSHCS partners with families, community providers and other state agencies to ensure access to quality services. Within Medicaid Health Plans (MHPs), eligible Medicaid enrollees (e.g., SSI, Blind and Disabled, Healthy Michigan Plan, etc.) who have qualifying diagnoses and meet criteria of severity and chronicity are also enrolled into CSHCS. These CSHCS/Medicaid dual enrollees are guaranteed access to primary care providers and a network of subspecialists and receive care coordination services through the MHP. Care coordination, case management, outreach and advocacy for blind and disabled individuals under the age of 16 receiving SSI are provided through CSHCS programs at local health departments.
The CSHCS Division includes five work areas. The Customer Support Section (CSS) processes medical eligibility determinations made by the Office of Medical Affairs (OMA), program applications for clients with qualifying diagnoses, and providers approved by OMA. CSS also conducts financial assessments; implements payment agreements; and issues and renews client program coverage. The Policy and Program Development Section (PPD) develops program policies; oversees implementation of program development plans; and develops and promotes transition strategies. PPD is responsible for administering the Insurance Premium Payment Benefit Assistance Program and provides oversight for care coordination through specialty clinics. Staff also help LHDs and families navigate complex billing issues. The Quality and Program Services Section (QPS) ensures program quality and improvement planning, monitors customer satisfaction, conducts LHD trainings, and assists LHDs in supporting clients (e.g., transportation and care coordination). The Children with Special Needs (CSN) Fund provides services and equipment to CSHCN not available through any other resource, including state or federal programs. The CSN Fund is available for Michigan residents under 21 who are eligible for CSHCS enrollment.
The Family Center for CYSHCN shapes CSHCS policies and programs by bringing a family perspective and helps families navigate the systems of care for CSHCN. Parent Consultants within the Family Center help to identify family needs; provide referral to resources; and connect parents to educational and emotional supports. Parent Consultants also promote the CSHCS program and provide trainings to help parents become advocates. Through its Parent-to-Parent Support Network, the Family Center provides emotional support and information to families. The statewide Family Leadership Network provides community-based perspectives on programs and policies and informs families of resources and services. The Family Phone Line provides another avenue of support and is available to any family that has a child with special needs.
III.C.2.b.ii.c. MCH Workforce Capacity
Michigan has many MCH leaders who provide strategic leadership and oversight to MDHHS programs and initiatives. Title V senior level leadership and program staff include:
- Dawn Shanafelt, MPA, BSN, RN, Director, Division of Maternal and Infant Health has 23 years of clinical and administrative public health experience at local and state levels. Ms. Shanafelt has served as the Title V MCH director since 2019. She administers Michigan’s maternal and infant health programs including Title X Family Planning, the Maternal Infant Health Program, and statewide initiatives to reduce maternal and infant mortality.
- Lonnie Barnett, MPH, Director, CSHCS Division has over 25 years of state and local public health experience in health administration, health planning, systems development, workforce development, and data-informed program development. Mr. Barnett has worked for MDHHS since 1998 and previously served as the Manager for the Health Planning and Access to Care Section. He has served as the Title V CSHCN Director since 2011.
- Carrie Tarry, MPH, Director, Division of Child and Adolescent Health has 20 years of state-level experience working in child health, adolescent and school health, and teen pregnancy prevention programs. She also oversees the MIECHV home visiting initiative and oral health programs and administers Title V funding to 45 local health departments.
- Sarah Davis, MPA, Departmental Specialist, Division of Maternal and Infant Health has 13 years of state-level experience in health and human services program coordination and grant management. She has served as the Title V block grant coordinator since 2015 and serves on state-level MCH committees and advisory boards.
- Theresa Christner, MA, CSHCS Policy and Program Development Section Manager, has more than 30 years of public health experience at the local and state level. She provides oversight to staff responsible for policy, healthcare transition services, specialty clinics, insurance premium payment benefit and billing assistance.
- Chris Fussman, MCH Epidemiology Section Manager has 12 years of state level experience with epidemiologic analysis and interpretation to inform and guide MCH program leaders and policy makers about population health.
- Lindsay Townes, MPH, Adolescent School Health Epidemiologist, has nearly a decade of experience in academic and government epidemiology. Ms. Townes provides epidemiological and data support to the Title V program, including comprehensive needs assessment activities and annual reporting.
- Trudy Esch, MS, BSN, RN, Nurse Consultant, Division of Child and Adolescent Health has worked for 37 years as a nurse, with 20 years in academia and 10 years of state level experience. She oversees contract monitoring for Title V local MCH services funded through 45 local health departments.
Additional managers and staff across MCH program areas provide oversight and administration of services funded by Title V. These include managers and staff in the Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program; the reproductive health unit; the infant health unit; the infant safe sleep program; the oral health unit; the adolescent and school health unit; and the Division of Immunization. Representatives from each Title V program area serve on the Title V steering committee to ensure a coordinated approach to Title V activities.
Title V funding currently supports five state-level positions that provide administrative support to the Title V block grant. Two positions provide oversight of the local MCH program; two positions provide epidemiological support; and one position provides coordination of all block grant activities. These positions are based in MDHHS central office in Lansing, Michigan. Only one LMCH position is supported in full by the Title V block grant; the remaining four positions are supported through blended funding (e.g., state general funds) as most positions have responsibilities in addition to Title V.
Approximately $105,000 of Title V funding helps to support the programmatic work of the Family Center for CYSHCN and its staff, which are paid positions:
- Candida Bush, Director, is a Certified Family Life Educator through the National Council on Family Relations. She is a parent of two young adults with special health care needs and has worked over 25 years to support, empower, and increase access to services for CSHCN.
- Lisa Huckleberry, Megan Mezel, Aleisha Leavitt, Ayanna Eggleston, Kate Jones (Parent Consultants) are parents of children with special health care needs or chronic health conditions. They have 40 years of combined experience advocating, educating, supporting, and providing direct care to individuals with special health care needs and their families. Parent consultants encourage, engage, and help to empower families to know the value and impact of their voice and their story.
- Dawn Adkins, Program Assistant, is a parent of two adult children with chronic health issues and continues to advocate for their health and the health of others.
- Christina Davis and Brenda Blair (Family Phone Line Representatives) are parents of children with special health care needs or chronic health conditions. They have 17 years of combined experience supporting and advocating for those with special health care needs.
The Title V needs assessment identified MCH workforce capacity and gaps. A provider survey was sent to individuals across the state who provide services to children and families to assess unmet needs impacting the MCH population. In total, 526 responses were captured. The top two survey respondents were Registered Nurses (n=90, 26.9%) and licensed childcare providers (n=65, 19.4%). The provider survey and other needs assessment data revealed that Michigan faces gaps in provider availability, including:
- A systemic lack of mental and behavioral health providers equipped to provide treatment specific to substance use disorders
- A shortage in medical and dental providers for CSHCN
- A statewide shortage of medical and dental providers that accept Medicaid
- A shortage of providers with open caseloads accepting new patients
- A limited numbers of obstetricians and birthing hospitals in rural areas
These findings related to gaps in provider availability align with other studies. A September 2019 Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) report concluded that Michigan required an additional 529 primary care providers to ensure Michiganders have access to primary care and that only 42% of Michiganders’ primary care needs are met. Similarly, an Altarum report identified a critical shortage of behavioral health providers in Michigan. Of the 1.76 million Michiganders experiencing a mental illness, about 62% receive treatment. Additionally, only 20% of Michiganders with a substance use disorder receive treatment.
MCH provider shortages in Michigan align with similar shortages across the US. The March of Dimes report Nowhere to Go: Maternity Care Deserts Across the US (2018) revealed an uneven distribution of MCH providers (OB/GYN, certified nurse-midwives, and family physicians) across the US, which contributes to access inequities in certain communities and rural areas. Almost half of US counties lack a single OB/GYN, and more than 20 million women lived in counties without an OB provider. The US also faces a critical shortage of Registered Nurses. According to the 2018 National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses (HRSA), 83% of licensed nurses were currently employed and 47.5% were over the age of 50. Michigan also faces an aging nursing workforce. Additionally, according to the 2019 Michigan Annual Nurse Survey 12.4% of Michigan nurses who provide direct patient care and 27% of nurses who do not provide direct patient care plan to leave the workforce in the next five years.
Equally problematic is the shortage of pediatric subspecialists, pediatric surgical specialists, child and adolescent psychiatrists, and advanced practice professionals. The Children’s Hospital Association Survey (2017) reports that nationwide, these shortages exacerbate burdens on families who experience long wait times for appointments and often must travel great distances to obtain care.
The needs assessment also found strengths and gaps in the degree to which the MCH workforce feels well prepared for their roles. When asked on the provider survey whether they agreed with the statement “My workforce has access to high-quality training specific to their role” 52% of respondents strongly agreed, 27% agreed, and 18% disagreed. Additionally, the needs assessment found:
- Longstanding MCH staff and leaders at the local and state level bring expertise and wisdom to the MCH system
- Michigan’s MCH system is collaborative and provides opportunities for statewide learning
- Providers need additional training and resources on cultural competency
- Providers need additional training and resources to assess and address patients’ basic needs
These findings can inform future efforts to strengthen Michigan’s MCH and public health workforce in partnership with MDHHS, local partners, and colleges and universities.
III.C.2.b.iii. Title V Program Partnerships, Collaboration, and Coordination
The Title V needs assessment utilized and built upon a wide range of partnerships and collaboration. Long-standing relationships between MDHHS and public and private organizations, service providers, and advocacy organizations were identified as a strength in the needs assessment. These relationships allow for collaborative and coordinated work which strengthens the ability to meet MCH population needs. For example, MDHHS provides Title V funding to local health departments to address MCH needs through local program implementation. MDE is also a close partner in programs supporting early childhood, school health, and child and adolescent health. MDE and MDHHS have a long history of integrated funding for early childhood, Child and Adolescent Health Centers, Hearing and Vision school-based screenings, and shared state-level positions.
Key Title V and MCH partnerships include the following: Children’s Special Health Care Services Advisory Committee; Children’s Trust Fund; Early Childhood Investment Corporation; Early Hearing Detection and Intervention (EHDI) Advisory Committee; Family Leadership Network; Family to Family Health Information Center; Great Start Operations Team; Health Disparities Reduction and Minority Health Section; Infant Safe Sleep State Advisory Team; Michigan Alliance for Families; Michigan Association for Local Public Health; Michigan Association of Health Plans; Michigan Breastfeeding Network; Michigan Council for Maternal and Child Health; Michigan Family Voices; Michigan Health and Hospital Association; Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance Committee; Michigan Primary Care Association; Michigan Oral Health Coalition; Regional Perinatal Quality Collaboratives; School-Community Health Alliance of Michigan.
Provider organizations such as the Michigan chapters of the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology, American Academy of Pediatrics and Society of Adolescent Medicine enhance health advocacy efforts and offer education and training. Several Michigan universities partner in program evaluation and in pilot projects to expand services, including projects in telemedicine and telepsychiatry. Tribal, youth-serving, faith-based, community-based and other non-profit organizations are often recipients of grant funds for service delivery and create linkages to service recipients, allowing MDHHS to uplift the consumer voice through consumer representation on advisory boards, councils and task forces.
Lastly, the Title V program regularly partners with other federal investments (including the State System Development Initiative, Newborn Screening, MIECHV, Healthy Start, Medicaid, and WIC) and state programs (including chronic disease and injury control, substance abuse prevention, behavioral health, vital records, and epidemiology). Many of these partnerships and collaborative initiatives are described throughout this application.
III.C.2.c. Identifying Priority Needs and Linking to Performance Measures
The findings from Michigan’s needs assessment drove identification of seven state priority needs which were used to select seven NPMs and six SPMs. The alignment between NPMs/SPMs, state priority needs, and population domains is illustrated in the NPM/SPM chart included as a Supporting Document. The needs assessment also identified three “pillars” that apply across Michigan’s state action plans.
The process of selecting state priority needs included two phases. First, the 50+ priority need statements developed by the population domain workgroups were reviewed to identify commonalities. Similar statements were consolidated, resulting in a list of 35 priority needs. Second, the priority need statements were reviewed to determine if they were within or outside the scope of Title V. As a result of this process, priority needs were sorted into five categories:
- Title V State Priority Needs
- Title V Pillars
- Needs Assessment Gaps
- MCH Priorities
- Priorities to Elevate beyond MCH
Priority needs in the first category were selected as Michigan’s Title V state priority needs for the next five-year cycle. They aligned with the purpose of Title V and could be linked to performance measures and/or used to develop SPMs. The Title V priority needs for 2021-2025 are:
- Develop a proactive and responsive healthcare system that equitably meets the needs of all populations, eliminating barriers related to race, culture, language, sexual orientation, and gender identity.
- Improve access to high-quality community health and prevention services in the places where women, children, and families live, learn, work, and play.
- Ensure children with special health care needs have access to continuous health coverage, all benefits they are eligible to receive, and relevant care where they learn and live.
- Expand access to developmental, behavioral, and mental health services through routine screening, strong referral networks, well-informed providers, and integrated service delivery systems.
- Improve oral health awareness and create an oral health delivery system that provides access through multiple systems.
- Create and enhance support systems that empower families, protect and strengthen family relationships, promote care for self and children, and connect families to their communities.
- Create safe and healthy schools and communities that promote human thriving, including physical and mental health supports that address the needs of the whole person.
The needs categorized as Title V pillars aligned with the purpose of Title V and were used to inform NPM and SPM state action plans. They reflected broad and overarching drivers of health outcomes and system effectiveness. The Title V pillars are:
- Build capacity to achieve equitable health outcomes by understanding and addressing the role of implicit bias and macro-level forces (such as racism, gender discrimination, and environmental degradation) on the health of women, infants, children, adolescents, and children with special health care needs.
- Intentionally and routinely find opportunities to seek the knowledge and expertise of communities and families in all levels of decision-making to build trust and create policies and programs that align with family and community needs.
- Deliver culturally, linguistically, and age-appropriate health education that reflects customer feedback, effectively uses technology, and reaches multiple audiences.
Needs in other categories will be carried forward in various ways. Three needs suggested gaps in the needs assessment and will be used to inform future assessment activities. Ten needs were identified that aligned with the work of broader MCH programs and partners. These priorities highlighted needs related to addressing social determinants of health, strengthening advocacy, diverse representation in the workforce, and respite care. These priorities can be considered through MCH programs beyond Title V and/or addressed through partnerships.
Lastly, ten needs were identified that are broader than Title V and the MCH system. These priorities included creating systems for whole person care, improving rural health care, addressing payment barriers and administrative and funding silos, abolishing racism and other forms of oppression, and creating equitable distribution of income. These findings will be shared with leadership in the Public Health Administration and with other system partners. For example, Michigan is currently conducting its State Health Assessment and these priorities will be elevated as part of that process.
Michigan developed its state priority needs in 2015 and 2020 through a comprehensive group process. In each cycle, dozens of MCH partners reviewed data and developed priority need statements independent of priorities that emerged from the prior assessment. Given this process, it is highly unlikely that the specific statements developed from one iteration of the needs assessment to the next would be the same. As such, Form 9 indicates all state priority needs as “new.” However, commonalities and differences emerged between the two cycles, as illustrated in Table 1.
Table 1: Alignment between FY 2016-2020 and FY 2021-2025 Priority Needs
|
FY 2016-2020 Priorities |
FY 2021-2025 Priorities |
|
Reduce barriers, improve access, and increase the availability of health services for all populations |
Develop a proactive and responsive healthcare system that equitably meets the needs of all populations, eliminating barriers related to race, culture, language, sexual orientation, and gender identity |
|
Invest in prevention and early intervention strategies |
Improve access to high-quality community health and prevention services in the places where women, children, and families live, learn, work, and play |
|
Foster safer homes, schools, and environments with a focus on prevention |
Create safe and healthy schools and communities that promote human thriving, including physical and mental health supports that address the needs of the whole person |
|
Increase family and provider support and education for Children with Special Health Care Needs |
Ensure children with special health care needs have access to continuous health coverage, all benefits they are eligible to receive, and relevant care where they learn and live |
|
Increase access to and utilization of evidence-based oral health practices and services |
Improve oral health awareness and create an oral health delivery system that provides access through multiple systems |
|
Promote social and emotional well-being through the provision of behavioral health services |
Expand access to developmental, behavioral, and mental health services through routine screening, strong referral networks, well-informed providers, and integrated service delivery systems |
|
Support coordination and linkage across the perinatal to pediatric continuum of care |
|
|
|
Create and enhance support systems that empower families, protect and strengthen family relationships, promote care for self and children, and connect families to their communities |
In both cycles, the needs assessments suggested gaps in access to healthcare, including physical, mental, behavioral, developmental, and oral health care. They also highlighted the need to expand or enhance key components of the service system for families, including preventive services, early intervention, and services for children with special needs. Both sets of priority needs also highlighted the need to partner with schools and communities to foster safety and wellbeing.
Compared to the 2015 needs assessment, the 2020 needs assessment resulted in priority needs more focused on equity and social determinants of health. It also focused more explicitly on integrated, whole-person care, as well as delivering care and services where people live, learn, work, and play. Finally, this needs assessment more explicitly focused on family partnership in defining need, shaping services, and driving improvement.
NPMs and SPMs were assessed and selected based on three main criteria: conceptual alignment between the measure and the priority need statement; the capacity of the Title V program to impact the measure (e.g., whether activities, funding, and/or leadership related to the measure are within the scope of Title V); and current performance based on population health data. Title V leadership determined whether state or local Title V resources were allocated toward the measure, and MCH epidemiologists examined each NPM and potential SPM to identify disparities, trends, and Michigan’s performance related to the US. Once NPMs and SPMs were selected they were vetted with the Title V Steering Committee and presented to the Needs Assessment Stakeholder Group.
The focus of Title V ongoing needs assessment activities in FY 2021 have been a COVID-19 Maternal and Child Health (MCH) Impact Assessment and a review of state action plans to assess health equity components. This section also discusses ongoing or emerging issues that impact the MCH population, including infant and maternal mortality, COVID-19 and pregnancy, health concerns specific to CSHCN, and the impact of COVID-19 on local health departments (LHDs).
COVID-19 MCH Impact Assessment
As part of Title V needs assessment activities, Michigan assessed the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on women, mothers, infants, children, adolescents, and CSHCN. In addition to the immediate health threats posed by COVID-19, the pandemic required changes to many aspects of daily life to reduce rates of infection and death and to avoid overwhelming the healthcare system. As Michigan worked to control the spread of COVID-19 and save lives, employment became less stable, childcare options changed, school and other programs moved online, telemedicine was broadened, and healthcare access changed. These experiences illustrated both strengths and gaps in systems for meeting families’ needs. While there is still much to learn about the immediate and long-term impact of COVID-19, Michigan’s Title V program used several methods to identify the current impact on MCH. In coordination with the Michigan Public Health Institute (MPHI), these included an MCH program staff survey; key informant interviews; a focus group; and a literature review. Findings from each assessment are described below.
COVID-19 MCH Impact Survey
Through an online survey conducted in February 2021, MDHHS MCH program staff (including but not limited to Title V programs) shared feedback about the impact of COVID-19 on the populations served by their programs. Data (primarily open-ended questions) were analyzed by population domain.
Programs serving infants and women during the perinatal period identified several factors that threatened the well-being of this population during the pandemic. They noted that families have experienced inconsistent income and employment, making it difficult to meet basic needs. They also described challenges related to social isolation and mental health, as well as difficulties accessing childcare. Families with young children have also needed better guidance for safety protocols related to sanitation and mask wearing.
Program staff noted that accessing services and interacting with the healthcare system has been a source of stress for pregnant women and infants. For example, limiting the presence of support people during delivery was a source of anxiety for some women. Additionally, decreased hospital stays after delivery have limited time for safe sleep education and breastfeeding support. Program staff also described difficulty providing health screenings. Challenges related to WIC included a shortage of WIC-approved foods and the lack of an approved method for using WIC benefits online or for curbside or delivery services. Program staff also noted that staff shifts to respond to COVID-19 have limited the delivery of other programs and services, such as safe sleep outreach and education.
However, program staff also described several strategies for adapting service delivery that have been successful. Education and training programs have been adapted to an online format, including childbirth classes, breastfeeding, and lactation support. Use of social media to share resources and education has expanded on topics such as safe sleep. Programs were also able to support local shifts and innovations, such as delivering needed resources to families contact-free and supporting LHD staffing pivots to cover COVID-19 activities. Program staff noted that expanded reimbursement for telehealth services has benefited families, and WIC waivers allowed families to access nutrition resources. Michigan’s Regional Perinatal Quality Collaboratives also supported local innovation. For example, they provided blood pressure cuffs to high-risk hypertensive mothers to monitor blood pressure at home when access to clinical care was limited.
Program staff in programs serving children noted similar challenges faced by this population during the COVID-19 pandemic. They described how the pandemic has compounded the challenges that vulnerable communities across the state already face. Inconsistent income and employment and lack of access to basic needs created stress for families and impacted mental health and substance use. Families enrolled in WIC also had difficulty with food access, as noted above. Changes in service delivery created challenges, with the pivot to virtual services difficult for some programs. Preventive care screenings and education decreased (e.g., for lead exposure). Mental health services and several types of screenings (e.g., vision and hearing) can be more difficult to provide virtually. Programs that deliver services to students, such as school-based dental programs, temporarily could not reach children during school closures.
Despite these challenges, program staff noted that several innovations in service delivery were successful for some children and families. Virtual home visiting created increased accessibility for some families. Online health education programs also expanded reach of some health education services. As noted above, removal of the USDA/WIC in-person certification requirements and additional approved foods improved access to WIC.
Program staff who serve adolescents also identified challenges to adolescent mental and behavioral health due to the pandemic. They noted that the pandemic led to stress and trauma, as well as isolation and disconnect from peers. Staff noted that the stressors of the pandemic disproportionally affected adolescents in minority groups, reflecting and compounding health inequities, and some adolescents faced increased food insecurity, violence in the home, and transportation issues. Staff felt uncertain about the lasting impacts of virtual schooling for adolescents. However, they noted that the shift to remote learning impacted the delivery of public health programs and services that are typically provided in schools.
Telehealth and adapted curriculum for virtual learning have been successful strategies to mitigate these challenges. Additionally, allowing programs such as the SEAL! Michigan dental program to reach children and adolescents outside of the school setting allowed for expanded reach. Additional settings, virtual delivery of programs, and flexible use of funds have been beneficial to reaching adolescents.
The CSHCN population experienced a heightened level of fear of exposure to COVID-19 creating stress and isolation. Program staff indicated that fear impacted choices on who to allow into the home for care and if/when to participate in routine health care, which is necessary for disease prevention and management. Program staff identified barriers to delivering school-based programs, especially for children with intellectual/developmental conditions who need school-based services like physical, occupational, and speech therapies. Additionally, the health system that serves CSHCN has also suffered with the closure of many physician and dental services, reduced home visitation, and staff diversion to COVID-19 duties at LHDs.
Although these challenges exist, CSHCN policy and program adaptations enabled care delivery during the pandemic. Michigan issued policies to ease obtaining medications and durable medical equipment, personal protective equipment for some diagnoses, removing face-to-face requirements to enable telehealth, and modifications to prior authorization policies. The use of telehealth and removing prior barriers (such as needing time off from work/school, transportation logistics, and travel costs) have been successful strategies for the continuation of care for CSHCN.
Impact on MCH Capacity
A question on the COVID-19 survey was “How has the COVID-19 pandemic impacted the state’s delivery of MCH services?” Some MCH programs were expanded, and many were adapted to support increased need during the COVID-19 pandemic. For example, the SNAP program was expanded to serve more families and children; home visitation services shifted to be offered virtually; and breastfeeding and childbirth education classes were provided virtually.
Another change in MCH program capacity resulted from shifting MDHHS staff and local public health staff to support contact tracing and vaccination efforts as part of the state’s emergency response. An example was the shift of MCH epidemiology staff to support COVID-19 case and death reporting data. While this flexibility enabled public health to respond to critical needs and gaps from the COVID-19 pandemic, it also created challenges for existing MCH programs.
The lasting impact of these changes is yet to be determined. The pandemic revealed capacity gaps in programs and services not only in Michigan, but across the country. The development of lessons learned and capacity adjustments as states move out of the emergency response will be critical to ensure future MCH program capacity.
Key Informant Interviews & Focus Group
Three key informant interviews focused on women, children, and adolescents and one focus group focused on CSHCN were held with MCH leaders outside of MDHHS who could speak to the impacts of COVID-19 on these populations. For CSHCN, a focus group was held with the CYSHCN Family Leadership Network (a statewide group comprised of caregivers, family members, and parents of CYSHCN) to ensure family and caregiver voice were elevated for a population uniquely impacted by COVID-19. The key informant interviews and focus group lasted 60-90 minutes. The sessions were facilitated by an MPHI staff member and were recorded. Transcripts were analyzed for major themes using Nvivo software.
Participants identified many ways the pandemic impacted the MCH population. First, participants described how the pandemic exacerbated challenges families face in meeting their basic needs, which highlighted the importance of social determinants of health. Public health measures that were essential to the health and safety of residents, such as social distancing, remote learning, and working from home, led to social isolation and stress for some families. The pandemic also resulted in temporary closures of some businesses and services, which led to instability in employment and income, access to childcare, and access to transportation. These factors led to an increased need for concrete support, as well as social-emotional support.
Second, participants reported that telehealth programs were helpful and made access to care possible during times when in-person care was inaccessible. However, some participants noted concerns about the quality of care since tactile treatments could not occur via video and some changes in health may not be as visible when not in person. Participants noted that families delayed care due to concerns about exposure to COVID-19 and therefore experienced gaps in preventive care, such as immunizations, lead testing, hearing and vision screening, and dental care.
Third, participants noted that health information and guidance were extremely important during the pandemic. Participants identified challenges accessing reliable information that was culturally relevant, science-based, and up to date for all MCH populations. Participants also emphasized the need to continue to build trust with communities most impacted by the pandemic and in relation to vaccine hesitancy.
Literature Review
MPHI staff conducted a review of recent peer reviewed research, grey literature, and news articles about the impacts of COVID-19 on Title V populations at national, state, and local levels. Criteria for the search were those that referenced COVID-19 and one or more Title V population domains, with specific focus on articles that impacted Michigan directly. Additional key terms included service delivery, health equity, pregnancy, breastfeeding, vaccine, insurance, response and preparedness, mental health, housing, and substance use. Key findings from the review are highlighted below (see Supporting Document for full citations).
The review shed light on the severe economic and social impacts of the pandemic across all Title V population domains, resulting in increased “rates of poverty, food insecurity, homelessness, intimate partner violence, and child abuse and neglect” (NIHCM, 2020). Increased mental health concerns were also highlighted across population domains (NAMI, 2020), ranging from mothers experiencing trauma due to giving birth alone (Mayopoulos, 2021), to children and adolescents experiencing social isolation (St. George, 2021), and CSHCN struggling without their usual supports (Children’s, 2020). Other challenges include securing childcare, addressing medical needs or having to delay care, and securing stable internet for work or distance learning (Martin, 2021; Waxman, 2020; RWJF, 2020). These challenges have exacerbated existing disparities as they disproportionately impact Latino, Black, and Native American communities; people with disabilities; rural populations; and the LGBTQ community (RWJF, 2020; The Trevor Project, 2021). Research also suggests that while most providers are using patient portals to disseminate vaccine information and schedule vaccination appointments, the age, race, and socioeconomic groups most affected by COVID-19 are least likely to use these portals (Malani, 2021).
To address these disparities, the literature emphasizes the critical first step of collecting and monitoring COVID-19 data by race, ethnicity, and other demographic characteristics (CDC Data, 2021). The State of Michigan created the Michigan Coronavirus Task Force on Racial Disparities to engage diverse stakeholders in combating structural racism across Michigan, with special focus on improving testing infrastructure, primary provider connections, centering equity, telehealth access, and environmental justice (MDHHS, 2020). At the national level, the U.S. Strategy for the COVID-19 Response and Pandemic Preparedness also outlines goals related to advancing equity (Office of President, 2021), and Medicaid has allowed states to temporarily expand eligibility and lift rules to serve more women and children (AMCHP, 2021).
The review also highlighted insights for each MCH domain. Early studies suggest pregnant women have an elevated risk of severe illness from COVID-19 and that those with severe illness have a greater risk of adverse pregnancy and birth outcomes (CDC Investigating, 2021; NIH, 2021). However, transmission from mother to infant seems to be rare, so enhancing breastfeeding supports is critical during this time, as well as continuing life-saving interventions for the most vulnerable infants (NIH, 2021; Perrine, 2020; Rao, 2021).
Research on children revealed widespread mental health issues and a significant drop in reports of child abuse due to less access by mandated reporters (St. George, 2021). A recent COVID-19 modeling study indicated that school reopening was associated with a slight increase in COVID-19 infections and deaths, but most of the transmission could be attributed to adults aged 20-49 and could be mitigated by vaccinating this age group (Monod, 2021). Administration of standard immunizations for other diseases has decreased nationally during the pandemic (Martin, 2021), a trend consistent with data on Michigan’s child and adolescent vaccination rates (MDHHS).
Adolescents have faced unique challenges in receiving services for substance use, with less referrals from schools, and with providers having capacity barriers and needing to shift to address basic needs (Freese, 2021). Sexual health providers for adolescents and adults have also had to shift service delivery, including using telehealth visits, at-home specimen collection, and referrals to pharmacists to avoid clinic visits (CDC Guidance, 2020).
Resources focused on CSHCN described sub-populations that should be prioritized once vaccinations have been approved for children, such as children living in congregate settings, those at higher risk of illness due to COVID-19, and those experiencing greater difficulties with distance learning (Randi, 2021). Guidance for local health departments in Michigan urged those working with CSHCN to update Plans of Care to incorporate pandemic planning and outlined other supports that may be needed, including home health care concerns; telehealth support and safe clinical visits; childcare options; and distance learning support (Children’s, 2020).
Overall, this review emphasized the importance of meeting basic needs and providing mental health supports during this time. Data show that marginalized groups are disproportionately impacted by the pandemic, so continuing to collect and act on the data will allow for an equitable approach, especially for vaccine distribution. Unique needs of the MCH population include continuing postpartum supports for birthing people and infants, addressing distance learning challenges for children and adolescents, and providing equitable access to resources for CSHCN and their caregivers.
Conclusion
This assessment began to uncover the most immediate implications of the COVID-19 pandemic for the MCH population. COVID-19 created an unprecedented threat to the health and well-being of Michiganders, with trauma and loss experienced by many families. Additionally, the public health measures required to reduce the spread of COVID-19 and save lives changed how we work and live. Fear and isolation were experienced across communities. However, the most vulnerable communities experienced deeper impacts. The findings of this preliminary assessment highlighted the systemic gaps in safety nets for children and families, as well as inequities in policies and systems. Systems were often unprepared to quickly pivot and ensure income stability and access to basic needs in a severe crisis, especially at the onset of the pandemic; parents experienced serious challenges focusing on their essential role; and reliance on schools and childcare programs to support the economy has never been clearer. Moreover, this crisis illustrated the implications of defunding or underfunding governmental public health such that it does not have the surge capacity necessary to expand capacity and continue normal operations within a pandemic. These challenging times have also presented opportunities for innovation and evolution and will continue to present learning opportunities to strengthen public health and MCH infrastructure in service of families and children.
Health Equity Action Plan Review
The five-year needs assessment identified the need to “achieve equitable health outcomes” for the MCH population, which was established as a Title V pillar across population domains. To further operationalize this pillar, in FY 2021 all Title V state action plans were reviewed to provide feedback to program staff on resources and recommendations for strengthening health equity efforts and strategies. MDHHS partnered with MPHI to develop a rubric to review the plans. The rubric was designed to provide concrete examples from research literature to adapt objectives or strategies to tackle root causes and strengthen the focus on health equity, diversity, and inclusion.
MPHI completed a review of each state action plan and provided written feedback that detailed strengths, opportunities for improvement or expansion (both immediate and long term), and links to research and/or best practices. Completed health equity rubrics were shared with Title V program staff and one-on-one virtual review sessions were offered. Program staff then updated state action plans for the FY 2022 application. Transforming state action plans to increasingly focus on equity and root causes of disparities will be an iterative process. Additionally, not all equity-focused work within programs is included in the Title V application due to the specific focus of the plans. It was also a challenging year to make extensive revisions to state action plans, as many MCH staff were involved in COVID-19 response efforts.
Ongoing and Emerging Issues that Impact MCH
Infant and maternal mortality remain two critical public health issues. Other current issues include COVID-19 and pregnancy, substance use, issues that impact CSHCN, and the impact of COVID-19 on local public health.
Infant and Maternal Mortality
MDHHS continues to closely monitor infant and maternal mortality and has seen the following trends and emerging concerns. The infant mortality rate in Michigan for 2019 was 6.4 deaths per 1,000 live births, which is the lowest infant mortality on record for Michigan. This decrease in the statewide infant mortality rate can be attributed, in part, to a corresponding decrease in the infant mortality rate in the City of Detroit. From 2018 to 2019, the infant mortality rate in the City of Detroit dropped from 16.7 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in 2018 to 11.0 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in 2019. Although improving, racial and ethnic disparities remain a major contributor to Michigan’s reported infant mortality rates. The Black infant mortality rate has continued to be nearly three times that of the White infant mortality rate (most recently, 12.5 versus 4.9 per 1,000 live births in 2019). The pregnancy-related mortality ratio in Michigan for 2017 was 9.9 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births[1]. As with infant mortality, disparities between Black and White mothers are striking, with the Black pregnancy-related mortality ratio more than two times that of the White rate (21.3 versus 8.9 per 100,000 live births based on 2013-2017 data). In addition to maternal deaths caused by pregnancy-related issues, addressing pregnancy-associated mortality[2] remains an important component of Title V work: 32.0% of all pregnancy-associated, not related deaths from 2013-2017 were caused by accidental poisoning/drug overdose. Michigan’s maternal mortality committees have focused efforts on developing recommendations to help prevent current and expecting mothers from developing opioid use disorders.
COVID-19 and Pregnancy
Michigan is participating in the CDC COVID-19 Pregnancy and Neonate Surveillance Project. For this project, women who have received a confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 during pregnancy are identified through the Michigan Disease Surveillance System (MDSS). This list is then linked monthly with birth and death certificates to track pregnancy outcomes. After each pregnancy outcome has taken place, medical records for both mother and infant are requested to obtain further details regarding the impacts of COVID-19 on the health of mother and infant.
As of early December 2020, 1,111 Michigan women were identified with a confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis during pregnancy. 564 (50.8%) of these women had a pregnancy outcome thus far. The majority of pregnancy outcomes were to White mothers (53.8%), while 28.5% were to Black mothers. All pregnancy outcomes were live births, with 16.5% of these live births classified as preterm births. The preterm birth percentage among this group is higher than the state average which is normally around 10%. Furthermore, the NICU admission percentage among this group is currently at 11.7%, which is higher than Michigan overall at 7.6%. Lastly, the infant COVID-19 positive rate is currently very low at 1.8% of live births to COVID-19 infected mothers. Additional statistics will be available as mothers who were infected within COVID-19 during their 1st trimester begin to have pregnancy outcomes.
In addition to this surveillance project, the Michigan Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (MI PRAMS) has added several COVID-19 questions to the survey. These questions were added shortly after COVID-19 surfaced in Michigan and will continue to be included within the 2021 MI PRAMS survey.
Substance Use
Figure 1. Map of 2019 NAS Rates by Prosperity Region
The number of drug exposed infants increased by 49% from FY 2010 to FY 2013, from 2,589 to 3,866 infants[3]. Additionally, infants hospitalized and treated for drug withdrawal symptoms has increased[4]. In 2010, 478 infants in Michigan had a diagnosis code of 779.5 (ICD-9-CM) and needed treatment for withdrawal from a drug, not specifically identified as opioids. In 2019, the number of infants with a diagnosis code of P96.1 (ICD-10-CM) increased to 673 infants. This represents a jump from 41.7 per 10,000 live births in 2010 to 62.4 in 2019. The opioid epidemic has also impacted maternal deaths. In 2011, 9% of maternal deaths were opioid related compared to 19% of maternal deaths in 2016[5].
MDHHS remains committed to supporting opioid use disorder prevention for pregnant and parenting women and women of childbearing age; increasing screening and identification; maintaining data collection and reporting; optimizing resource allocation to target resources to those in greatest need; developing a quality improvement system; and improving workforce development and training programs. MDHHS also has created many Opioid Resources to provide assistance and to decrease stigma related to opioid use and treatment.
The DMIH has also partnered with the MDHHS Office of Recovery Oriented Systems of Care to provide funding to three health systems to implement ‘rooming in’ programs in their birthing units. The rooming-in program is a family-centered model that encourages mother-infant bonding and utilizes non-pharmacological care of infants born substance-exposed, ensuring they remain with their mother or caregiver in a private hospital room that is less stimulating for the infant (i.e., room-darkening shades, softer flooring, etc.). The rooms are often equipped with murphy beds or sleeper chairs to enable an additional caregiver to stay at the hospital. Hospital staff provide education and support to the mother and family (e.g., for breastfeeding, skin-to-skin contact, calming techniques, and referrals to services like home visiting). The rooming-in program supports bonding between mother and infant, decreases the length of stay for babies diagnosed with NAS, and promotes positive parenting and recovery from substance use disorder.
Children with Special Health Care Needs
There is an emerging focus on Children with Medical Complexity (CMC) who suffer from one or more chronic conditions that affects three or more organ systems or one-life limiting illness or rare pediatric disease. Nationwide, CMC make up less than 4% of the total children’s population but are estimated to account for 40% of Medicaid’s pediatric spending. Using population, claims and encounter data, CSHCS is conducting an assessment within its program population to identify the number of children who meet this definition and would potentially benefit from a more intensive service array to improve their care coordination and quality of life. The Advancing Care for Exceptional (ACE) Kids Act should create opportunities for states to improve systems of care for CMC.
Efforts to apply a health equity lens have contributed to a greater awareness of disparities in access to health care experienced by individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD) which disproportionately affects African Americans. It is estimated that between 3,500 to 4,000 Michiganders are living with SCD. Of those, 798 are children enrolled in CSHCS and 2,317 are adult Medicaid recipients. Individuals with SCD are prone to higher rates of hospitalization, emergency room utilization, and premature death. In FY 2021, CSHCS partnered with the Lifecourse Epidemiology and Genomics Division to submit a proposal to the Governor’s Office to expand clinical services and enhance the system of care serving clients with SCD. The proposal was accepted and included in the Governor’s FY 2022 budget recommendation. The proposal will expand CSHCS coverage to adults, resulting in improved continuity of care and transition to adult providers, and will establish clinical pathways that address inequities in access to care.
Impact of COVID-19 on Local Public Health
Michigan’s 45 LHDs all reported challenges in 2020 related to the COVID-19 pandemic. Many LHDs had temporary closures for months during the state’s stay home order, others operated with reduced hours. Staff were shifted from their program areas to pandemic response such as testing, contact tracing, case investigation, hotline staffing, and addressing exposure sites. This shift in focus resulted in a domino effect. LHDs have reported projects or programs halted, less children immunized and screened for lead, decreased medical appointments, and decreased call volume for program assistance. School buildings closed which also limited the reach of LHD programs to children and adolescents. LHDs worked during the pandemic to adjust logistics and restructure programs and services to virtual platforms. LHD staff provided assistance through telephone calls, virtual platforms, and telehealth visits when possible.
[1] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy from any cause related to or aggravated by the pregnancy or its management. Data source: Maternal Deaths in Michigan, 2013-2017 Data Update. MDHHS. Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance Program.
[2] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy due to a cause unrelated to pregnancy.
[3] Data from Michigan’s Services Worker Support System.
[4] Data from Michigan Inpatient Hospitalization Files.
[5] Division for Vital Records and Health Statistics, MDHHS.
Title V needs assessment activities in FY 2022 have focused on a second COVID-19 MCH Impact Assessment and a review of state action plans to assess family and community engagement. Ongoing or emerging issues that impact the MCH population are also discussed in this section, including infant and maternal mortality, COVID-19 and pregnancy, substance use, fluoridation, and health concerns specific to children and youth with special health care needs (CYSHCN).
COVID-19 MCH Impact Assessment
As the COVID-19 pandemic persisted, Michigan’s MCH and Title V programs continued to focus on identifying and responding to the needs of women, mothers, infants, children, and CYSHCN. The impact assessment used several methods to explore impacts in 2021, including an MCH impact survey, analysis of local MCH (LMCH) workplans, and a literature review. Findings are described below.
COVID-19 MCH Impact Survey
MDHHS MCH program staff completed an 18-item online survey in February 2022. The survey asked respondents to share their experiences and observations about the impact of COVID-19 on the populations served by their programs. Questions focused on provision of services and health information, workforce challenges, and emerging needs. Michigan Public Health Institute (MPHI) analyzed findings from 24 respondents which included, but was not limited to, Title V programs.
Figure 1. MCH Populations Served by Survey Respondents
Seventeen out of 24 respondents indicated their program provided information, technical assistance, or education on COVID-19 and/or COVID-19 vaccines to individuals, families, providers, or local grantees in 2021. In addition to COVID-19 information, programs indicated they provided guidance on telehealth services and resources on mental health and social isolation. Programs shared information via websites, flyers, newsletters, toolkits, and townhalls.
Notably, most state programs that received Title V funding indicated that they did not use funding for COVID-19 related activities in 2021.
Figure 2. Use of Title V Funding
COVID-19 presented challenges for MCH programs in service delivery and staffing capacity. Twenty-three respondents indicated that their program provided services virtually or via telehealth due to limited ability to provide in-person services, as indicated in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Service Provision
Programs such as home visiting, nutrition support, family planning, and mental health services adapted to virtual and telephonic delivery. Exemptions for telehealth reimbursement eased service delivery. Virtual programs made services more accessible for harder to reach populations, and some programs are interested in continuing to offer this option.
Most survey respondents noted workforce challenges and indicated they were most pronounced for local programs, as illustrated in Figure 4.
Figure 4. Workforce Challenges
In addition to staff shortages, turnover, and reassignment due to COVID-19, respondents indicated that other challenges included staff burnout and mental health concerns.
Struggles with social isolation, stress, job security, housing, and food access affected Michiganders across MCH domains centering the need for mental health support. Provider shortages impeded addressing this need. Programs leveraged technology to provide virtual case managers and therapy sessions to address the critical need. Most respondents indicated that COVID-19 impacted groups differently, as indicated in Figure 5.
Figure 5. COVID-19 Impact
These impacts are discussed below.
Findings by Population Domain
Programs that served women and infants identified persistent barriers to in-person activities, such as lactation and breastfeeding support, WIC redemption, and oral health services. Populations with low-income, people living in both rural and urban areas, and people of color had exacerbated experiences from the pandemic’s economic impacts. Job and food security, affordable housing, and childcare were common concerns. However, programs continued to provide concrete supports, such as pack and plays, through no contact means.
Child and adolescent programs reported a heightened need for mental and oral health services, in-person screenings, and academic supports. School closings, academic delays, and social isolation were noted as challenges. School restrictions also limited screenings and services for vision, hearing, blood lead testing, and oral health which particularly impacted low-income, rural, and urban youth. Adaptations extended the reach of school-based programs by connecting with target populations outside of school. For example, technology allowed case managers to meet with clients, deliver mental health services to youth, and use the Michigan Model for Health.
Programs that served CYSHCN reported challenges navigating the telehealth landscape and the stress of exposure at in-person visits, causing some families to delay medical care. Private nurses and respite care for families with CYSHCN were also more difficult to access. However, policies and exemptions reduced burdens for medication and medical equipment access, telehealth reimbursement, and vaccine administration. Collaboration was noted as a strength. For example, grants to local health departments promoted vaccine delivery to CYSHCN.
Local MCH Workplan Analysis
Year-end LMCH reports from Local Health Departments (LHDs) were analyzed with a focus on understanding the effects of the pandemic on the LMCH program, which is funded by Title V. Expenditures and persons served were quantified and categorized by performance measure, and workplans were analyzed for qualitative themes.
Across the state, LHDs addressed over 120 goals and served 360,850 individuals. Out of 45 LHDs,18 LHDs expended $892,060 (14.6%) in Title V funding to combat COVID-19, serving 187,799 clients. Over half of total individuals served by LMCH were reached with COVID-related services, most commonly vaccinations.
LHDs noted many challenges. For example, the pandemic forced programs to divert both funding and staff to address needs related to contact tracing, case investigation, testing, vaccination, and information hotlines. Limited in-person services were also a barrier to meeting goals. Virtual WIC appointments resulted in fewer immunizations, screenings, and lactation support services. Canceled community events also limited programs’ ability to implement outreach and education activities. While programs adjusted to provide services via telehealth, several programs reported difficulty sustaining virtual programming due to providers’ lack of comfort, poor phone access or internet connections (especially in rural areas), or patient preference. Collecting evaluation data also proved difficult in a virtual format.
LHDs shared successful efforts to serve their community despite limited in-person interaction. Many used alternative communication methods such as print and radio ads, and especially social media, to educate the public on COVID-19 and other health topics. Some programs used virtual events to engage community members. Several LHDs reported partnering with local providers and businesses to reach more people.
Literature Review & Annotated Bibliography
MPHI reviewed recent peer-reviewed and grey literature on the impacts of COVID-19 on MCH populations (see Supporting Documents for the Annotated Bibliography). Search criteria included COVID-19 references and one or more Title V population domains, with a focus on articles about Michigan. Other key terms were service delivery, health equity, pregnancy, breastfeeding, vaccine, insurance, mental health, and substance use.
The review reinforced prior findings on the physical, mental, and social impacts of the pandemic across all population domains and the disparities among demographic groups. In addition, emerging research highlights the direct and indirect long-term impacts on individuals and society.
Scholars continued to assess the phenomenon of ‘long COVID’ and ‘long haulers’ who experience symptoms for months after testing positive for the virus, which can include children (University of California Davis, 2022). A University of Michigan study found 27% of Michiganders who contracted COVID-19 in 2020 reported having a disability following their illness versus 15% before onset (Michigan News, 2022). In turn, specialty clinics have arisen to research and treat higher risk ‘long hauler’ adult and pediatric patients coping with multisystem inflammatory syndrome in children (Michigan Medicine, 2021).
COVID-19 vaccines saved lives in the U.S. and in Michigan (Gupta, 2021; Samson, 2021). Yet inequity and access barriers, mis/disinformation about the vaccine, and mistrust of healthcare systems affected the adoption of this intervention (Clay, 2021). As of March 30, 2022, 67% of Michigan residents had received their first dose—markedly lower than the overall U.S. rate of 82% (MDHHS, 2022; CDC, 2022). Rates vary by race in Michigan, with only 45% of Black residents having their first dose, compared to 56% of White residents (MDHHS, 2022).
Impacts on mental health continued in Michigan, often contributing to substance use issues (Slootmaker, 2022). From April 2020 to April 2021, Michigan opioid-related drug overdoses rose 19% over the prior year. Factors included “isolation, boredom, financial stress, loss of loved ones,” and lack of basic needs. Black, Indigenous, and Hispanic populations, people under age 24, people involved in the criminal justice system, and mothers and infants were especially affected by opioid use and deaths.
To address mental and other health concerns, telehealth options expanded, but access was inequitable. Income and insurance status limited access to telehealth, as did internet access (Darrat, 2020). To reduce inequities, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services launched the Telehealth Broadband Pilot Program to expand access and improve broadband connectivity in rural areas of many states including Michigan (Augenstein, 2022).
In addition to these overarching impacts, the review highlighted insights unique to each MCH domain.
A Southeast Michigan study confirmed research that pregnancy elevates the risk of severe illness from COVID-19; suggests pregnant people have a higher risk of early preeclampsia after COVID-19 infection; and indicates that Black pregnant people are twice as likely as White pregnant people to contract early preeclampsia after COVID-19 (Ismailova, 2022). While studies have shown that COVID-19 vaccination of pregnant people is safe and effective (even in protecting the baby), the vaccination rate in this group has remained low.
A national study described the pandemic’s impact on birthing practices, including elevated emotional distress and adverse breastfeeding experiences due to lack of postpartum social support, shifting birthing plans due to hospital policy changes, a disconnect between expectation and reality, and some surprising benefits (such as better bonding with partner and infant) (Shuman, 2022). The pandemic “increased patients’ and policymakers’ interest in alternative care models like birth centers and doula services” over traditional interventions and hospitals (Burroughs, 2021). Expanding access to health insurance and telehealth can facilitate these options, and “expanding and diversifying the maternal health workforce is critical for promoting more culturally and linguistically effective care and addressing inequities” in birth outcomes.
Healthcare disruptions also impacted infants needing neonatal intensive care. Barriers to infants receiving care from NICU nurses included difficulty establishing skin-to-skin contact, problems caused by personal protective equipment, and fear of COVID-19 (Celık, 2021). Mothers faced barriers to providing care to their infants such as lack of family visits, interrupted kangaroo care, and difficulties breastfeeding.
Children also experienced barriers to healthcare during the pandemic. According to a national survey, “26.4% of households reported that ≥1 child or adolescent had missed or delayed a preventive visit because of COVID-19.” This was more likely among respondents who reported material hardships. Common reasons for missing or delaying preventive visits were concern about visiting a health care provider, limited appointment availability, and closed provider locations (Lebrun-Harris, 2022). Missed appointments led to fewer opportunities for lead testing, which decreased during the pandemic nationally and in Michigan (Michigan CLPPP, 2021; Courtney, 2020). Similarly, opportunities were missed to immunize children against vaccine-preventable illnesses. In May 2020 in Michigan, “vaccination coverage declined in all milestone age cohorts [year over year], except for birth-dose hepatitis B coverage…and coverage was lower for Medicaid-enrolled children than their peers” (Bramer, 2020).
As of March 30, 2022, COVID-19 vaccination of Michigan youth aged 5-19 was 41%, with a racial disparity of 40% of White youth compared to 28% of Black youth receiving at least one dose. Asian American and Hispanic/Latinx American youth rates were higher, 66% and 43% respectively, which increased the overall rate. Youth aged 5-11 lagged at 28% compared to 52% for youth aged 12-19 (MDHHS, 2022).
Abrupt school closures in 2020 worsened food insecurity for many students. States struggled to obtain and disburse funds for student meals due to administrative and data sharing barriers (Waxman, 2021). The adverse implications of distance learning on students were also documented (Harvard, 2021). Mental health care infrastructure for children has been overwhelmed by surges in emergency mental health needs and severe labor shortages. This unmet need is especially acute in rural areas of Michigan, such as the Upper Peninsula and northern Lower Peninsula (NIHCM Foundation, 2021; Erb, 2021).
As adult and pediatric COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations peaked due to the Omicron variant, hospitals were short-staffed and had difficulty providing surgeries for serious non-COVID illnesses (Fromson, 2022). Michigan Medicine found many Omicron cases were among younger children and adolescents displaying pneumonia and multisystem inflammatory syndrome.
Adolescents experienced increased mental health issues, with some groups at higher risk due to social and environmental factors (Office of the Surgeon General, 2021). These groups include youth with intellectual and developmental disabilities, racial and ethnic minority youth, youth who have low-income or live in rural areas, youth in immigrant households, foster care or justice system-involved youth, and youth who identify as LGBTQ+. The pandemic elevated stress levels among LGBTQ+ youth with almost half indicating their mental health counseling needs were unmet (The Trevor Project 2021).
Similarly, high school students reported increased “feelings of boredom, anxiety, depression, loneliness, worry, difficulty sleeping, and other negative mental health indicators since the beginning of the pandemic” (NIH, 2021). However, they also reported the largest single-year drop in substance use since the study began in 1975, including alcohol, marijuana, and vaped nicotine. Authors attributed this behavior change to changes in the daily life of adolescents related to “drug availability, family involvement, differences in peer pressure, or other factors.”
Parents of CYSHCN experienced increased stress caused by persistent challenges including “disruption in day care, health care, and employment, and loss of technological and therapeutic supports.” Many of these parents reported substance use including alcohol, cannabis, or other drugs (American, 2021).
Many policies improved CYSHCN access to health care by relaxing Medicare and Medicaid requirements, reducing administrative requirements for specialty services (Silow-Carrol, 2021). Expanded telehealth largely benefited CYSHCN, but low-income and rural families faced barriers such as lack of a device or broadband access. Experts emphasize the need to include CYSHCN and caregivers in emergency preparedness planning to reduce inequities and ensure that diverse needs are met. The U.S. Surgeon General also emphasized the need to address mental health needs, given unique pandemic challenges: “youth with intellectual and developmental disabilities…found it especially difficult to manage disruptions to school and services such as special education, counseling, occupational, and speech therapies” (2021).
Overall, this review emphasized the growing mental health crisis and the need for support. Groups that have been marginalized are disproportionately impacted by the pandemic, and efforts to address the impacts must target upstream social determinants and root causes. The unique needs of each MCH population require attention, including supporting new mothers and their infants, encouraging COVID-19 vaccination and childhood immunizations, and preventing and treating substance use.
Family and Community Engagement Action Plan Review
Michigan’s Title V five-year needs assessment identified three cross-cutting “pillars” that are critical across all MCH population domains. In 2022, Michigan focused on the pillar to “intentionally and routinely find opportunities to seek the knowledge and expertise of communities and families in all levels of decision making to build trust and create policies and programs that align with family and community needs.” To further integrate this pillar, MDHHS partnered with MPHI to review each Title V state action plan using a family and consumer engagement rubric. The aim was to identify strengths and opportunities to improve family and consumer engagement across plans.
MPHI reviewed all state actions plans and provided completed rubrics to Title V program staff. Feedback included examples and resources from the literature, and virtual technical assistance was provided upon request. During the TA sessions, program staff discussed the rubrics and ideas for integrating increased family and consumer engagement into FY 2023 state action plans or future activities.
Ongoing and Emerging Issues that Impact MCH
Infant and maternal mortality remain critical public health issues. Other current issues include COVID-19 and pregnancy, COVID-19 vaccination, substance use, community water fluoridation, and issues that impact CSHCN.
Infant and Maternal Mortality
MDHHS closely monitors infant and maternal mortality and has seen the following trends and emerging concerns. The infant mortality rate in Michigan for 2020 was 6.8 deaths per 1,000 live births, which represents a slight increase from 2019 (6.4 deaths per 1,000 live births). This increase in infant mortality could partially be attributed to a corresponding increase in the infant mortality rate within the City of Detroit. From 2019 to 2020, the infant mortality rate in the City of Detroit increased from 11.0 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in 2019 to 14.6 infant deaths per 1,000 live births in 2020. Although improving, racial and ethnic disparities remain a major contributor to Michigan’s infant mortality rates. The Black infant mortality rate has continued to be nearly three times that of the White infant mortality rate (13.6 versus 5.2 per 1,000 live births in 2020). The pregnancy-related mortality ratio in Michigan for 2018 was 10.9 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births[1]. As with infant mortality, disparities between Black and White mothers exist, with the Black pregnancy-related mortality ratio nearly three times that of the White rate (24.1 versus 8.5 per 100,000 live births based on 2014-2018 data). In addition to maternal deaths caused by pregnancy-related issues, addressing pregnancy-associated mortality[2] remains important: 36.1% of all pregnancy-associated, not related deaths from 2014-2018 were caused by accidental poisoning/drug overdose. Michigan’s maternal mortality committees have focused on developing recommendations to help prevent current and expecting mothers from developing opioid use disorders.
COVID-19 and Pregnancy
Michigan continues to participate in the CDC COVID-19 Pregnancy and Neonate Surveillance Project. For the project, women who have received a confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 during pregnancy are identified through the Michigan Disease Surveillance System (MDSS) which is then linked with birth and death certificates to track pregnancy outcomes. After each pregnancy outcome has taken place, medical records for both mother and infant are requested to obtain details regarding the impacts of COVID-19 on the health of mother and infant.
For the 2020 cohort, 1,378 Michigan women were identified with a confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis during pregnancy. A pregnancy outcome was confirmed for 1,288 (93.5%) with the remaining 90 women (6.5%) lost to follow-up. The 1,288 documented pregnancy outcomes resulted in 1,316 live births and less than five fetal deaths. The majority of pregnancy outcomes were to White mothers (65.6%) while 18.9% were to Black mothers. Among the 1,316 live births, 10.4% were classified as preterm births, which is similar to the state average of 10%. The NICU admission percentage among this group was 9.3%, which is higher than Michigan overall at 7.5%. Lastly, the infant COVID-19 positive rate was very low at less than one percent of live births to COVID-19 infected mothers. Michigan recently started working on the 2021 cohort.
In addition to this surveillance project, the Michigan Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (MI PRAMS) added COVID-19 questions to the survey. Results from the 2020 MI PRAMS COVID-19 questions indicate that an estimated 2.6% of new Michigan mothers reported that a health care worker told them they had COVID-19 during their most recent pregnancy, and it was confirmed through testing. When including mothers that were told by a health care worker that they had COVID-19 during their most recent pregnancy but they weren’t tested, this number increases to an estimated 3.7% (which represents 3,589 new mothers in 2020). Black, non-Hispanic mothers were nearly twice as likely to report COVID-19 during their most recent pregnancy when compared to white, non-Hispanic mothers.
COVID-19 Vaccination
The chart below provides Michigan COVID-19 vaccine coverage percentages by age group as of March 5, 2022. Initiation is defined as the percentage of Michigan residents who have received 1 or more doses of any vaccine, while completion is defined as the percentage receiving 2 doses of Pfizer or Moderna or 1 dose of Johnson & Johnson. Approximately one quarter of Michigan residents aged 5-11 years have either initiated or completed a COVID-19 vaccination. Initiation and completion rates increase to around 50% for those aged 12-29 years and increase to 60% or above for Michigan residents aged 30 years and above.
Substance Use
Opioid use during pregnancy and, as a result, an increase in the number of infants diagnosed with Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome (NAS) continues to be an issue in Michigan. Figure 1 details the incidence of NAS by region. As illustrated by the map, rural areas of Michigan have been hardest hit by this epidemic.
Figure 1. Map of 2020 NAS Rates by Prosperity Region
Additionally, infants hospitalized and treated for drug withdrawal symptoms has increased[3]. In 2010, 478 infants in Michigan received a diagnosis code of 779.5 (ICD-9-CM) which indicates a drug withdrawal syndrome, not specifically related to opioids. In 2020, 650 infants received a diagnosis code of P96.1 (ICD-10-CM), which indicates neonatal withdrawal symptoms from maternal use of drugs of addiction. This represents a jump from 416.7 per 100,000 live births in 2010 to 624.1 per 100,000 live births in 2020. The opioid epidemic has also impacted maternal deaths. In 2011, 9% of maternal deaths were opioid related compared to 32% of maternal deaths in 2018[4].
MDHHS remains committed to supporting substance use disorder (SUD) prevention for pregnant and parenting people and people of childbearing age; increasing screening and identification of SUD; maintaining data collection and reporting; optimizing resource allocation to target resources to those in greatest need; and improving workforce development and training programs.
DMIH has partnered with the MDHHS Office of Recovery Oriented Systems of Care to provide funding to three health systems to implement ‘rooming in’ programs in birthing units. The rooming-in program is a family-centered model that encourages parent-infant bonding and utilizes non-pharmacological care of infants born substance-exposed, ensuring they remain with their birthing parent or caregiver in a private hospital room that is less stimulating for the infant (e.g., room-darkening shades, softer flooring). The rooms are often equipped with murphy beds or sleeper chairs to enable an additional caregiver to stay at the hospital. Hospital staff provide education and support to the birthing parent and family (e.g., breastfeeding, skin-to-skin contact, calming techniques, and referrals to services). The rooming-in program supports bonding between parent and infant, decreases the length of stay for babies born substance exposed, and promotes positive parenting and recovery from substance use disorder.
Fluoridation
In 1945, Community Water Fluoridation (CWF) began in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Over the last 75 years, it has proven to be a safe and effective measure in the prevention of cavities. Over the past few years and during the pandemic, anti-fluoridation groups have attempted to tie faulty science to community water fluoridation. Nationally, municipal water systems that have had an interruption in their supply line for fluoride have come under pressure to stop fluoridating. In Michigan, three cities have seen a push to stop fluoridating. As an overlapping challenge, the once robust School Mouth Rinse Program has ended with the last manufacturer discontinuing production. CWF continues to be the most equitable form of oral public health. The removal of this fluoride delivery system would leave many children at risk of tooth decay and poorer oral health outcomes.
Children with Special Health Care Needs
Efforts to apply a health equity lens have contributed to a greater awareness of disparities in access to health care experienced by individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD) which disproportionately affects African Americans. An estimated 3,500 to 4,000 Michiganders are living with SCD. Of those, 798 are children enrolled in CSHCS and 2,317 are adult Medicaid recipients. Individuals with SCD are prone to higher rates of hospitalization, emergency room utilization, and premature death. In FY 2021, CSHCS partnered with the Lifecourse Epidemiology and Genomics Division to submit a proposal to the Governor’s Office to expand CSHCS eligibility to adults with SCD, expand clinical services, and enhance the system of care serving clients with SCD. The proposal was included in the Governor’s FY 2022 budget recommendation and implemented on October 1, 2021. CSHCS continues to implement outreach strategies to reach adults who can benefit from the CSHCS eligibility expansion. In addition, CSHCS is implementing strategies to expand the CMDS clinic model to include adult clinics caring for patients with SCD and developing toolkits for transition programs to improve transition to adulthood in this population.
Improved access to respite care for families with children with special health care needs was identified as a need in the 2020 Needs Assessment. According to the 2019-2020 National Survey of Children’s Health, parents/caregivers of children with special health care needs in Michigan are five times more likely to have left a job, requested a leave of absence, or reduced their work hours due to the stress of their child’s health or health conditions. In response, CSHCS has convened a workgroup comprised of representatives from Program Review Division, CSHCS, Office of Medical Affairs, and the Managed Care Plan Division to assess the current landscape for respite care in Michigan and explore opportunities to expand the CSHCS respite benefit.
[1] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy from any cause related to or aggravated by the pregnancy or its management. Data source: Maternal Deaths in Michigan, 2014-2018 Data Update. MDHHS. Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance Program.
[2] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy due to a cause unrelated to pregnancy.
[3] Data from Michigan Inpatient Database Files.
[4] Division for Vital Records and Health Statistics, Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance System, MDHHS.
Ongoing and emerging issues that impact the MCH population are discussed in this section, including infant and maternal mortality, COVID-19 and pregnancy, COVID-19 vaccination, routine childhood vaccination trends, the impact of the COVID-10 pandemic on local public health, the unwinding of the Public Health Emergency and Medicaid continuous enrollment, fluoridation, and health concerns specific to children and youth with special health care needs (CYSHCN). Additionally, Title V needs assessment activities in FY 2023 focused on assessing the public health workforce and broadband access for service delivery, which are also discussed in this section.
Ongoing and Emerging Issues that Impact MCH
Infant and Maternal Mortality
MDHHS closely monitors infant and maternal mortality and has seen the following trends and emerging concerns. The infant mortality rate (IMR) in Michigan for 2021 was 6.2 deaths per 1,000 live births, which is another lowest on record IMR. The last lowest on record IMR occurred in 2019. Racial and ethnic disparities remain a major contributor to Michigan’s infant mortality rates. The gap between the Black and white infant mortality rate widened in 2021. The Black infant mortality rate was more than three times that of the White infant mortality rate (13.6 versus 4.4 per 1,000 live births in 2021). The pregnancy-related mortality ratio in Michigan for 2019 was 23.2 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births[[1]]. As with infant mortality, disparities between Black and white mothers exist, with the Black pregnancy-related mortality ratio nearly three times that of the white rate (29.8 versus 10.7 per 100,000 live births based on 2015-2019 data). In addition to maternal deaths caused by pregnancy-related issues, addressing pregnancy-associated, not related mortality[[2]] remains important: 37.9% of all pregnancy-associated, not related deaths from 2015-2019 were caused by accidental poisoning/drug overdose. Michigan’s maternal mortality committees have focused on developing recommendations to help prevent current and expecting mothers from developing substance use disorders.
COVID-19 and Pregnancy
Michigan continues to participate in the CDC COVID-19 Pregnancy and Neonate Surveillance Project. For the project, women who have received a confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 during pregnancy are identified through the Michigan Disease Surveillance System (MDSS) which is then linked with birth and death certificates to track pregnancy outcomes. After each pregnancy outcome has taken place, medical records for both mother and infant are requested to obtain details regarding the impacts of COVID-19 on the health of mother and infant.
For the 2020 cohort, 1,378 Michigan women were identified with a confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis during pregnancy. A pregnancy outcome was confirmed for 1,288 (93.5%) with the remaining 90 women (6.5%) lost to follow-up. The 1,288 documented pregnancy outcomes resulted in 1,316 live births and less than five fetal deaths. Black pregnant persons were 3.4 times more likely to have a COVID-19 complication than white pregnant persons. Infants of Black parenting persons that were diagnosed with COVID-19 during pregnancy were 2.5 times more likely to be low birthweight compared to infants of white parenting persons that were diagnosed with COVID-19 during pregnancy. Furthermore, birthing parent races other than white were 1.2 times more likely to be in the COVID-19 cohort than those without a COVID-19 diagnosis during pregnancy. Michigan is currently completing data collection for the 2021 project cohort.
In addition to this surveillance project, the Michigan Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (MI PRAMS) added COVID-19 questions to the survey. Results from the 2020 MI PRAMS COVID-19 questions indicate that an estimated 2.6% of new Michigan mothers reported that a health care worker told them they had COVID-19 during their most recent pregnancy, and it was confirmed through testing. When including mothers who were told by a health care worker that they had COVID-19 during their most recent pregnancy but they weren’t tested, this number increases to an estimated 3.7% (which represents 3,589 new mothers in 2020). Black, non-Hispanic mothers were nearly twice as likely to report COVID-19 during their most recent pregnancy when compared to white, non-Hispanic mothers. Michigan is awaiting the final 2021 Michigan PRAMS data file from the CDC. Similar analyses will be conducted on the COVID-19 questions.
COVID-19 Vaccination
Table 1 provides Michigan COVID-19 vaccine coverage percentages by age group as of January 14, 2023. Initiation is defined as the percentage of Michigan residents who have received 1 or more doses of any vaccine; completion is defined as the percentage receiving 2 doses of Pfizer or Moderna or 1 dose of Johnson & Johnson, and up to date is defined as the percentage who have received the Pfizer or Moderna Bivalent Booster. Just over one quarter of Michigan residents aged 5-11 years have either initiated or completed their initial COVID-19 vaccinations, but less than 5% of this group are up to date on their COVID-19 vaccinations (i.e., received Pfizer or Moderna Bivalent Booster). Initiation and completion rates increase to around 50% for those aged 12-29 years and increase to 60% or above for Michigan residents aged 30 years and above. Most of the Michigan population is not up to date with COVID-19 vaccinations.
Table 1. COVID-19 Vaccine Coverage Percentages by Age Group
Priority Childhood Vaccinations
Table 2 provides Michigan child vaccination percentages for January through September 2022. When compared to the US average, Michigan reports lower immunization percentages for each of the main childhood vaccinations. Table 3 provides information on child vaccination percentages in Michigan over time. Since the first quarter of 2020 (January-March 2020), Michigan has experienced consistent decreases in each of the priority childhood vaccinations.
Table 2. Michigan Childhood Vaccination Rates in Comparison to US
|
Child Vaccination (19 through 35 months) |
||
|
|
Michigan Coverage (%) |
US Average (%) |
|
4313314* |
67.7 |
75.4 |
|
43133142* |
55.4 |
- |
|
2+ Hepatitis A |
57.4 |
77.4 |
|
4+ DTap (Diphtheria/Tetanus/Pertussis) |
70.5 |
87.2 |
|
PCV Complete (Pneumococcal) |
76.5 |
86.0 |
Table 3. Michigan Childhood Vaccination Rates Over Time
|
|
Percentage by end calendar year quarter |
|||||||
|
2020Q1 |
2020Q2 |
2020Q3 |
2021Q3 |
2021Q4 |
2022Q1 |
2022Q2 |
2022Q3 |
|
|
4313314* |
73.1 |
70.7 |
70.3 |
70.4 |
69.9 |
68.5 |
67.5 |
67.7 |
|
43133142* |
57.3 |
53.9 |
55.8 |
57.6 |
56.8 |
55.4 |
54.5 |
55.4 |
|
4+ DTap |
75.6 |
73.2 |
72.9 |
73.0 |
72.6 |
71.1 |
70.2 |
70.5 |
|
PCV Complete |
81.9 |
80.2 |
79.3 |
79.2 |
79.0 |
77.6 |
76.4 |
76.5 |
*4313314(2): 4 DTaP, 3 Polio, 1 Measles/Mumps/Rubella (MMR), 3 Hib, 3 Hepatitis B, 1 Varicella, 4 PCV, (2 Hepatitis A)
Impact of COVID-19 on Local Public Health
In 2022, the MDHHS Division of Local Public Health held site visits with 40 of 45 Local Health Departments (LHDs) to obtain feedback about the impacts of COVID-19. Conversations with LHD staff revealed that both the immediate and longer-term impacts of the pandemic have been significant and far-reaching for staff, families, and communities. LHD staff described trauma in the form of battle fatigue, lost leave, threats to staff and leadership, heartbreak at the community response, and mental and behavioral health challenges. State and local staff turnover was another challenge that resulted in loss of institutional knowledge. LHD staff also noted the need to promote workplace flexibility and to rebuild relationships with the community. They suggested that flexibility in background and experience in hiring may also help to mitigate staff turnover.
Staff also described how LHDs have had to contend with misinformation. Additionally, the ending of the public health emergency impacted Medicaid, WIC, and MIHP eligibility. Essential worker funds have been exempted from LHDs all but one time, significantly impacting morale and retention. Reengagement with LPH services, including clinical services, especially WIC and Immunizations, has become necessary. After Action Reporting has been proposed to capture the response in a useful form for the future. Despite the many challenges, there have been positives, such as the Michigan National Guard (MING) partnership, establishment/strengthening of regional lab systems, volunteers in the community, and CDC Foundation surge staffing.
Unwinding of the Public Health Emergency and Medicaid Continuous Enrollment
During the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), state Medicaid agencies were required to continue health care coverage for all medical assistance programs, even if a person’s eligibility changed. The end of the PHE on May 11, 2023, triggered the unwinding of the Medicaid continuous enrollment provision which ends on March 31, 2023. Starting in June, Michigan Medicaid beneficiaries will have to renew their coverage as the state resumes eligibility redeterminations. MDHHS has taken many steps to make beneficiaries aware of the redetermination requirements and to help individuals retain Medicaid coverage if eligible. MDHHS communications provide consistent messages about three key steps for Medicaid beneficiaries related to the redetermination process and avoiding gaps in coverage: make sure contact information is up to date; report any changes to a household or income; and complete a renewal packet by the due date, if eligible. A Medicaid Benefit Changes website provides information on the PHE, eligibility renewal timeline, an FAQ document, and resources for Medicaid providers and community partners. A stakeholder toolkit includes a “Get Ready” flyer in English, Spanish, and Arabic; a platform to request redetermination materials in English, Spanish, and Arabic (e.g., wallet cards, posters, and animated files); Medicaid renewal information; and a Beneficiary Renewal Alert Letter example. MDHHS will also launch a multi-media campaign with radio ads, mobile and social media ads, audio streaming, and outdoor ads.
MDHHS issued a press release about the unwinding on February 15, 2023, which included information related to individuals who are no longer eligible for Medicaid:
Michiganders who no longer qualify for Medicaid will receive additional information about other affordable health coverage options available, including on HealthCare.gov. Affected Michiganders will be able to shop for and enroll in comprehensive health insurance as they transition away from Medicaid, and many Michiganders can purchase a plan for less than $10 per month. Renewals for traditional Medicaid and the Healthy Michigan Plan will take place monthly starting in June 2023 and run through May 2024. Monthly renewal notices will be sent three months prior to a beneficiaries’ renewal date starting with June renewal dates.
To help ensure that the MCH population continues to receive Medicaid services and, if no longer eligible, avoids gaps in coverage, MCH programs have shared information about the unwinding with partners and program recipients. For example, the Child and Adolescent Health Center (CAHC) Program provided detailed information on the unwinding to school based/linked health centers and School Wellness Program sites. Information included MDHHS information and resources, a link to the MDHHS stakeholder toolkit, and tips for how CAHCs—since they provide Medicaid outreach and enrollment assistance onsite—can help families navigate the redetermination process.
The CSHCS program reached out to Medicaid partners to provide an overview of the unwinding and redetermination process for the CSHCS Advisory Committee. The Advisory Committee is comprised of organizations (providers, disease specific organizations, etc.) and parent/family members with a focus on children with special needs. A discussion about the redetermination process will focus on how CSHCS stakeholders can support clients with redetermination eligibility. Additionally, potential loss of Medicaid coverage due to the end of the PHE could have cost implications for the CSHCS program. CSHCS dual enrollment with Medicaid increased during the PHE. If dual enrollment numbers return to pre-Covid levels, it will lead to an increase in non-Medicaid costs for the CSHCS Title V medical care and treatment program.
Michigan’s MCH programs will continue to monitor the unwinding and redetermination processes and identify ways to assist partners and clients, so that everyone who is eligible for Medicaid benefits continues to receive them.
Fluoridation
In 1945, Community Water Fluoridation (CWF) began in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Over the last 78 years, it has been a safe and effective strategy in the prevention of cavities. The US Surgeon General states that CWF is one of the most cost-effective, equitable, and safe measures communities can take to prevent tooth decay and improve oral health. Over the past few years, anti-fluoridation groups have grown more visible. Nationally, municipal water systems that have had an interruption in their supply line for fluoride have come under pressure to stop fluoridating. In a northern Michigan community, the city council recently voted to discontinue community water fluoridation due to the lack of supply and increased costs despite community support of fluoridation. The once robust School Mouth Rinse Program has ended with the last manufacturer discontinuing production. The removal of this fluoride delivery system leaves many children at risk of tooth decay and poorer oral health outcomes.
Children with Special Health Care Needs
Application of a health equity lens has contributed to greater awareness of disparities in access to health care experienced by individuals with sickle cell disease (SCD) which disproportionately affects African Americans. An estimated 3,500 to 4,000 Michiganders are living with SCD. Individuals with SCD are prone to higher rates of hospitalization, emergency room utilization, and premature death. In FY 2021, CSHCS partnered with the Lifecourse Epidemiology and Genomics Division (LEGD) to submit a proposal to the Governor’s Office to expand CSHCS eligibility to adults with SCD, expand clinical services, and enhance the system of care serving clients with SCD. The proposal was embraced by the Governor and enacted in the FY 2022 budget appropriation. In FY 2022, 421 adults were enrolled with CSHCS. The program continues to implement outreach strategies to reach adults who can benefit from the CSHCS eligibility expansion, while also partnering with colleagues in LEGD to enhance clinical capacity to serve individuals with SCD. In addition, CSHCS is implementing strategies to expand the CMDS clinic model to include adult clinics caring for patients with SCD and developing toolkits for transition programs to improve transition to adulthood.
Improved access to respite care for families with CSHCN was identified as a need in the 2020 Needs Assessment. According to the 2019-2020 National Survey of Children’s Health, parents/caregivers of children with special health care needs in Michigan are five times more likely to have left a job, requested a leave of absence, or reduced their work hours due to the stress of their child’s health or health conditions. In response, CSHCS engaged with Partners for Children which completed a survey of 15 states to identify respite gaps and reached out to the Catalyst Center for additional evidence to support a policy change for CSHCS respite. CSHCS convened an internal workgroup with representation from Program Review Division, CSHCS, Office of Medical Affairs, and other partners to review and revise existing CSHCS respite policy. The committee has identified eligibility criteria and is in the process of estimating the population that would benefit from this policy change.
Literature Review
In 2023, a literature review was completed to understand more about the public health workforce and broadband access in Michigan. The full literature review, including citations, is included as a Supporting Document to this application. Highlights are included below.
Public Health Workforce
The public health workforce is essential to protecting and promoting the health and wellbeing of Michigan’s population of over 10 million people. The workforce is responsible for a range of essential services, including disease prevention and control, environmental health, emergency preparedness and response, health education, and health policy development. The COVID-19 pandemic exerted significant pressure on the public health system, including the maternal and child health system, and highlighted gaps that were compounded by the lack of investment into the state’s public health infrastructure, which has been understaffed and underfunded for many years (Bridge Michigan, 2023).
The strain on Michigan’s public health infrastructure is further exacerbated by several other challenges facing the public health workforce. One of the biggest challenges is the shortage of public health professionals in the state. According to a report by the National Public Health Information Coalition (NPHIC), there is a significant nationwide shortage of public health professionals, especially among nurses (NPHIC, 2021). Michigan ranked 5th in the highest number of mental health HPSAs, after California, Texas, Arkansas, and Missouri. The state ranked 6th in the highest number of primary care HPSAs and 7th in the highest number of dental health HPAs (HRSA, 2022).
Figure 1. Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs)
Source: Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, 2022
According to 2022 data from the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), 55 of 83 counties in Michigan (66%) were considered whole area dental care shortage areas. A higher percentage of counties (71%) were considered whole area primary care shortage areas, while 86% of counties in Michigan were considered whole area mental health shortage areas.
Figure 2. Dental Care, Primary Care, and Mental Health HPAs, by County, 2022 – Michigan
|
Dental Care HPAs
|
Primary Care HPAs
|
Mental Health HPAs
|
Source: Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, 2022
Although these shortages were observed before the pandemic, they were exacerbated by stressors placed on the workforce during the pandemic. Several factors contribute to the shortage of public health workers in Michigan, including:
- Burnout, Stress, and Trauma
- Aging Workforce
- Lack of Funding and Low Pay
The need for additional specialized skills and training is another obstacle facing the public health profession in Michigan. Finally, there is a need for a more diverse public health workforce in Michigan. According to the PH WINS, the public health workforce is not representative of the communities it serves, particularly in terms of race and ethnicity. This lack of diversity can limit the effectiveness of public health programs and services in reaching and engaging communities of color.
To address workforce issues in the state, Michigan has implemented several initiatives to support the maternal and child health workforce and increase access to care for these populations. For example, the state has established loan repayment programs and other financial incentives to encourage mental health providers to provide direct service and physicians to practice in underserved areas. Additionally, Michigan has implemented telehealth programs to expand access to care in rural areas. Another potential solution includes increasing the number of healthcare professionals trained to provide maternal and child healthcare services in rural areas.
Broadband Access
Michigan is a state with diverse geography and population, ranging from urban areas like Detroit and Grand Rapids to rural and remote communities in the Upper Peninsula and Northern Lower Peninsula. Although more communities have access to broadband in recent years than in the past, significant disparities in broadband access remain. According to a report by the Michigan Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity (LEO), which houses the newly established Michigan High-Speed Internet Office (MIHI), an estimated 1.24 million Michigan households (31.5%) do not have a permanent, fixed internet connection at home and an additional 865,000 households face barriers related to cost, adoption, or digital literacy. The lack of access is more severe in rural areas and among low-income families, communities of color, and individuals with disabilities. According to LEO, “Black and Latino Michiganders are nearly half as likely to have a home broadband connection than non-Black or Latino residents” and “nearly 35% of households earning less than $20,000 annually do not have a broadband connection.” These disparities in access have implications for public health, as they can limit access to health information, public health services, telemedicine, and eHealth technologies, particularly for under-resourced communities and populations. The map below shows the availability of broadband service with speeds of at least 25 Mbps download in Michigan.
Figure 3. Broadband Service with Speeds of at Least 25 Mbps Download/3 Mbps Upload – Michigan
Source: Connected Nation Michigan, 2021
The lack of broadband access can have significant public health implications for residents of Michigan. Limited access to telemedicine can limit the ability of residents to receive timely and appropriate medical care. Initial data suggest that employing virtual care to replace some traditional in-person sessions, such as home visiting, may be a positive long-term alternative for some families and some types of services. Telemedicine can be particularly important for individuals living in rural areas or those with mobility challenges.
Strategies to Improve Broadband and Telehealth Access
Strategies have been proposed to address the digital divide and improve public health outcomes in Michigan. These strategies include:
- Increasing broadband infrastructure in rural areas
- Providing affordable internet and technology
- Improving digital literacy and accessibility
- Partnering with community organizations
- Leveraging telehealth technology
Michigan has taken several steps to address the digital divide and promote public health broadband access, including the creation of the Michigan Broadband Roadmap, which was developed by the Michigan Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity (LEO) in collaboration with stakeholders from government, industry, and community organizations. The roadmap aims to identify gaps in broadband infrastructure and services, prioritize investment and deployment strategies, and promote public-private partnerships to expand access.
Broadband Funding Opportunities and Initiatives
Another important strategy for promoting public health broadband access in Michigan is the use of federal funding programs, such as the Connect America Fund (CAF) and the Rural Digital Opportunity Fund (RDOF). These programs provide subsidies and grants to broadband providers to expand their networks to unserved and underserved areas, including rural and low-income communities.
Other state-level programs include Connecting Michigan Communities (CMIC). The Michigan Department of Technology, Management, and Budget (DTMB) is offering a grant to extend broadband service to unserved Michigan areas. The grant funds are available for projects that demonstrate collaboration to achieve the area's community investment and economic development objectives. Statewide funding of $20 million was allocated to this grant program for the 2019 application year. The initial round of awards has been announced, and next year, approximately $15 million is anticipated to be allocated to this program.
Conclusion
The public health infrastructure in Michigan plays a critical role in promoting and protecting the health of communities. However, the public health workforce is facing a range of challenges, including an aging workforce, shortages of certain types of professionals, low compensation, stress and trauma, and a need for workforce development and training. By addressing these challenges and seizing these opportunities, Michigan can support a robust and effective public health workforce that is well-equipped to meet the needs of its diverse communities.
Technology and access to broadband can be leveraged to further strengthen public health infrastructure and access to services. Improving broadband access for people of childbearing age, pregnant people, infants, children, adolescents, and children and youth with special health care needs in Michigan is critical to improving public health outcomes and reducing health disparities for these populations.
By implementing innovative strategies, Michigan can improve public health outcomes for all residents, including those who are currently unserved and marginalized. By continuing to prioritize the public health workforce and broadband access as essential elements of an effective public health system, Michigan can make progress towards improving health outcomes and reducing health disparities for the MCH and CSHCN populations.
[[1]] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy from any cause related to or aggravated by the pregnancy or its management. Data source: Maternal Deaths in Michigan, 2014-2018 Data Update. MDHHS. Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance Program.
[[2]] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy due to a cause unrelated to pregnancy.
Ongoing and emerging issues that impact the MCH population are discussed in this section, including infant and maternal mortality, Congenital Syphilis, COVID-19 vaccination, COVID-19 and pregnancy, priority childhood vaccinations, the unwinding of the Public Health Emergency and Medicaid enrollment, and fluoridation. Health concerns specific to Children and Youth with Special Health Care Needs (CYSHCN) are also discussed and include children with medical complexity, Sickle Cell Disease, and respite care for families with CYSHCN.
Michigan’s Title V program is in the process of implementing the next five-year needs assessment, which is due in July 2025. This has included developing the needs assessment framework, goals, structures, and processes and implementing assessment activities. Additionally, the Title V program has been identifying ways to address the new universally required National Performance Measures (Postpartum Visit in the Women/Maternal Health Domain; Medical Home in the Child Health Domain; and Medical Home in the CSHCN Domain) which are included as state action plans in this application and will also be included in the next five-year cycle for FY 2026-2030.
Ongoing and Emerging Issues that Impact MCH
Infant and Maternal Mortality
MDHHS closely monitors infant and maternal mortality and has seen the following trends and emerging concerns. The infant mortality rate (IMR) in Michigan for 2022 was 6.4 deaths per 1,000 live births. This is a slight increase from the lowest on record IMR in 2021 at 6.2 deaths per 1,000 live births. Racial and ethnic disparities remain a major contributor to Michigan’s infant mortality rates. Although the gap between the Black and White infant mortality rate decreased slightly since 2021, when the Black infant mortality rate was more than three times greater than the corresponding White infant mortality rate, the 2022 gap is still higher than the disparity in 2020. In 2022, the Black Non-Hispanic infant mortality rate was 2.8 times that of the White Non-Hispanic infant mortality rate (13.3 versus 4.8 per 1,000 live births). The pregnancy-related mortality ratio in Michigan for 2020 was 43.2 maternal deaths per 100,000 live births[[1]]. As with infant mortality, disparities between Black and White mothers exist, with the Black pregnancy-related mortality ratio 2.2 times that of the White ratio (36.5 versus 16.3 per 100,000 live births based on 2016-2020 data). In addition to maternal deaths caused by pregnancy-related issues, addressing pregnancy-associated, not related mortality[[2]] remains important: 35.7% of all pregnancy-associated, not related deaths from 2016-2020 were caused by accidental poisoning/drug overdose.
Michigan’s maternal mortality review committee has focused on developing recommendations to help prevent current and expecting mothers from developing substance use disorders. In 2024, a new report Maternal Deaths in Michigan Data Update, 2016-2020 was released and provides a high-level overview of Michigan’s pregnancy-associated deaths, including determination of pregnancy-relatedness, demographics, disparities, causes of death, preventability and recommendations to prevent future deaths. Additionally, Michigan’s fatality review programs have been working together to create a process for coordinating, collaborating, and elevating aligned prevention recommendations. The newly released report Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance (MMMS) and Fetal Infant Mortality Review (FIMR) Aligned Recommendations is intended to amplify shared/aligned strategies for prevention of maternal, fetal, and infant deaths.
Congenital Syphilis
Michigan, like much of the nation, is experiencing an alarming increase in Congenital Syphilis (CS) cases. The debilitating outcomes of untreated Syphilis in utero include deformed bones, severe anemia (low blood count), enlarged liver and spleen, jaundice (yellowing of the skin or eyes), and brain and nerve problems including blindness or deafness. In 2023, Michigan saw an increase of 238% since 2019 with 54 cases, three stillbirths and one infant death reported. This vertical transmission, from mother to infant, parallels the increase in female syphilis cases due to increased heterosexual exposure. The geographic, race, and ethnicity distribution of these cases is 55% Black with 40% residing in Detroit, reflecting a large disparity among African Americans. The maternal age group most affected is 20-39. Michigan data suggest that a lack of adequate prenatal care is the most common factor contributing to CS, as two thirds of cases received little or no prenatal care.
CS is preventable if a pregnant person receives appropriate and timely testing and treatment. Early identification of syphilis through a serology test is crucial. Initiation of syphilis treatment in a pregnant person at least 30 days before delivery averts CS. Therefore, it is important for clinicians to adhere to Michigan’s Perinatal Screening Guidelines that require screening in the first trimester, again in the early third trimester (28 weeks), and at delivery if no record of previous testing or declination is documented. Notably, this law applies to all pregnant persons in Michigan, and all settings where pregnant persons access medical care, not just traditional prenatal providers.
MDHHS is committed to supporting community partners to prevent CS. Efforts include:
- Print resources for clinicians and their patients can be found here.
- Partner with MDHHS Medicaid Program to develop pregnancy screening performance measures that follow Michigan’s perinatal guidelines for managed health care plans.
- Fund an Electronic Medical Record (EMR) Best Practice Alerts (BPA) project in Southeastern Michigan. The alerts will indicate whether an emergency department patient may be indicated for an HIV, HCV, and/or syphilis test based on algorithms that will flag individuals most likely to benefit from related services.
- Support an HIV/syphilis clinician consult program through a major health system.
- Enhance patient follow up services to support clinicians.
- Awareness building by providing physician detailing and large group presentations for clinicians.
Michigan’s Maternal and Congenital Syphilis Fact sheet can be found here.
COVID-19 Vaccination
Table 1 provides Michigan COVID-19 vaccine coverage percentages by age group as of January 3, 2024. At Least One Dose is defined as the percentage of Michigan residents who have ever received any type of COVID-19 vaccine in their lifetime; Updated 2023-2024 is defined as the percentage being up-to-date based on the CDC recommendation for the 2023-2024 season. Nearly 33% of Michigan residents aged 5-11 years have had at least one COVID-19 vaccine in their lifetime, but only 5% of this group are up to date on their COVID-19 vaccinations for the 2023-2024 season.
The percentage of ever having received a COVID-19 vaccination increases steadily with age and is the highest, at 95%, among those aged 75+ years. The updated 2023-2024 percentage also increases with age, but at a slower rate. Less than 12% of Michigan residents aged 64 years or less are fully vaccinated based on the current CDC recommendations. Michigan residents aged 75+ years have the highest percentage for up-to-date COVID-19 vaccinations at just over 36%.
Table 1. COVID-19 Vaccine Coverage Percentages by Age Group
COVID-19 and Pregnancy
With the completion of the 2021 cohort, Michigan has concluded its participation in the CDC COVID-19 Pregnancy and Neonate Surveillance Project. For the project, women who received a confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 during pregnancy during 2020 and/or 2021 were identified through the Michigan Disease Surveillance System (MDSS) which was then linked with birth and death certificates to track pregnancy outcomes. After each pregnancy outcome occurred, medical records for both mother and infant were requested to obtain details regarding the impacts of COVID-19 on the health of mother and infant.
For the 2020 cohort, 1,378 Michigan women were identified with a confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis during pregnancy. A pregnancy outcome was confirmed for 1,288 (93.5%) with the remaining 90 women (6.5%) lost to follow-up. The 1,288 documented pregnancy outcomes resulted in 1,316 live births and less than five fetal deaths. Black pregnant persons were 3.4 times more likely to have a COVID-19 complication than White pregnant persons. Infants of Black parenting persons that were diagnosed with COVID-19 during pregnancy were 2.5 times more likely to be low birthweight compared to infants of White parenting persons that were diagnosed with COVID-19 during pregnancy. Additional results from the 2020 cohort can be found within the full COVID-19 and Pregnancy factsheet. Plans are in place to analyze the 2021 cohort data and develop another factsheet.
Priority Childhood Vaccinations
Table 2 provides Michigan child vaccination percentages for July through September 2023. When compared to the US average, Michigan reports lower immunization percentages for each of the main childhood vaccinations. Table 3 provides information on child vaccination percentages in Michigan over time. Since the third quarter of 2021 (October-December 2021), Michigan has experienced consistent decreases in each of the priority childhood vaccinations.
Table 2. Michigan Childhood Vaccination Rates in Comparison to US
|
Child Vaccination (19 through 35 months) |
||
|
|
Michigan Coverage (%) |
US Average (%) |
|
4313314* |
66.8 |
75.4 |
|
43133142* |
54.3 |
- |
|
2+ Hepatitis A |
56.1 |
77.4 |
|
4+ DTap (Diphtheria/Tetanus/Pertussis) |
69.7 |
87.2 |
|
PCV Complete (Pneumococcal) |
74.9 |
86.0 |
Table 3. Michigan Childhood Vaccination Rates Over Time
|
|
Percentage by end calendar year quarter |
||||||||
|
2021 Q3 |
2021 Q4 |
2022 Q1 |
2022 Q2 |
2022 Q3 |
2022 Q4 |
2023 Q1 |
2023 Q2 |
2023 Q3 |
|
|
4313314* |
70.4 |
69.9 |
68.5 |
67.5 |
67.7 |
66.1 |
65.8 |
65.9 |
66.8 |
|
43133142* |
57.6 |
56.8 |
55.4 |
54.5 |
55.4 |
53.3 |
52.8 |
52.4 |
54.3 |
|
4+ DTap |
73.0 |
72.6 |
71.1 |
70.2 |
70.5 |
69.1 |
68.9 |
68.9 |
69.7 |
|
PCV Complete |
79.2 |
79.0 |
77.6 |
76.4 |
76.5 |
75.0 |
74.5 |
74.4 |
74.9 |
*4313314(2): 4 DTaP, 3 Polio, 1 Measles/Mumps/Rubella (MMR), 3 Hib, 3 Hepatitis B, 1 Varicella, 4 PCV, (2 Hepatitis A)
MCH Vaccination Efforts
To address and support COVID-19 vaccination as well as other routine vaccination among the MCH population, MCH program activities include the following:
- Child and Adolescent Health Centers (CAHCs) provide school-based or school-linked comprehensive primary and preventive health and mental health services for children and adolescents ages 5-21 years. CAHCs help students keep vaccination status up to date by providing any needed vaccines. CAHCs directly supported influenza and COVID-19 vaccination efforts during the pandemic. In FY 2023, CAHCs provided 23,674 immunizations to students.
- The Division of Maternal and Infant Health hired a Public Health Nurse Consultant (PHN) in 2021 within the Maternal Infant Health Program (MIHP) to focus on immunization efforts. In 2022, the PHN worked with a marketing firm to develop and launch a campaign to increase awareness of immunizations. In 2023, a training module was developed to provide education related to immunization among pregnant people, infants, and their families. This module is required for all MIHP home visitors and includes information related to immunization recommendations, motivational interviewing, vaccine hesitancy, and disparities in vaccination rates. The consultant also reviews and develops immunization content for the MIHP Bi-Weekly Update email newsletters and for the phone application Pregnancy+. To increase awareness and share resources, federal immunization awareness campaigns such as National Immunization Awareness Month and National Infant Immunization Week are shared. The PHN also provided an Immunization Update webinar in February 2024. Assessment of immunization status has been integrated into MIHP protocols and a Quality Assessment review that took place from 2023-2024. Additionally, a comprehensive vaccine education toolkit is under development in 2024 to provide home visitors with a user-friendly tool for enhancing communication with families.
- The CSHCS Vaccine Initiative addresses vaccination gaps in CYSHCN and their families. Funding was provided to LHDs to improve access to COVID-19 vaccines; expand vaccination education, messaging, and partnerships; and improve understanding of barriers to vaccination. The funding for this project ended in June 2023.
Unwinding of the Public Health Emergency and Medicaid Continuous Enrollment
During the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), state Medicaid agencies were required to continue health care coverage for all medical assistance programs, even if a person’s eligibility changed. The end of the PHE on May 11, 2023, triggered the unwinding of the Medicaid continuous enrollment provision. Starting in June 2023, Michigan Medicaid beneficiaries had to renew their coverage as the state resumed eligibility redeterminations. MDHHS took many steps to make beneficiaries aware of the redetermination requirements and to help individuals retain Medicaid coverage if eligible. Those activities were discussed in detail in last year’s Title V application.
Current information on renewals is available on the Michigan Medicaid Renewals Data website. A press release issued by MDHHS on January 31, 2024, indicates that more than 1.1 million Michigan Medicaid beneficiaries had their coverage renewed six months into the renewal process. Several strategies have been used to ease the renewal process and mitigate the risk of coverage loss, including extending renewals to May 2024 for beneficiaries undergoing life-saving treatment and providing beneficiaries an extra month to submit paperwork. Michigan’s MCH programs will continue to monitor the unwinding and redetermination processes and assist partners and clients, as needed, so that individuals who are eligible for Medicaid benefits continue to receive them.
In particular, the potential loss of Medicaid coverage could have cost implications for the CSHCS program. The CSHCS program hosted Medicaid partners at a CSHCS Advisory Committee meeting to provide an overview of the unwinding and redetermination process. The Advisory Committee includes organizations (providers, disease-specific organizations, etc.) and parent/family members with a focus on children with special needs. The discussion included general information on the unwind process and the anticipated impacts on CSHCS clients. CSHCS continues to monitor enrollment trends closely. CSHCS dual enrollment with Medicaid increased during the PHE. Current data indicate total enrollment is trending toward pre-COVID levels with decreases in CSHCS clients dually enrolled in Medicaid.
Fluoridation
In 1945, Community Water Fluoridation (CWF) began in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Over the last 79 years, it has been a safe and effective strategy in the prevention of cavities. The US Surgeon General states that CWF is one of the most cost-effective, equitable, and safe measures communities can take to prevent tooth decay and improve oral health. Over the past few years, anti-fluoridation groups have grown more visible. In a northern Michigan community, the city council recently voted to discontinue community water fluoridation due to the lack of supply and increased costs despite community support of fluoridation. The once robust School Mouth Rinse Program has ended with the last manufacturer discontinuing production. The removal of this fluoride delivery system leaves many children at risk of tooth decay and poorer oral health outcomes. MDHHS is continuing to monitor fluoridation activities around the state.
Children with Special Health Care Needs
Nationwide, there is an emerging focus on Children with Medical Complexity (CMC) who suffer from one or more chronic conditions and experience high healthcare utilization. CSHCS estimates that CMC make up less than 4% of the CSHCS population but are estimated to account for 40% of Medicaid’s pediatric spending. To address the complex needs of this population, CSHCS is collaborating with Michigan Medicaid, Michigan Medicine, Michigan-based Children’s Hospitals, and stakeholders to explore the establishment of a targeted case management benefit for CMC in Michigan. The goals of the CMC program are to improve patient outcomes, increase patient and family satisfaction, and reduce healthcare costs by enhancing the systems of care for CMC and, more broadly, CYSHCN.
Sickle Cell Disease (SCD) is a chronic condition which disproportionately affects African Americans. An estimated 3,500 to 4,000 Michiganders are living with SCD. Individuals with SCD are prone to higher rates of hospitalization, emergency room utilization, and premature death. In FY 2021, CSHCS partnered with the Lifecourse Epidemiology and Genomics Division (LEGD) to submit a proposal to the Governor’s Office to expand CSHCS eligibility to adults with SCD, expand clinical services, and enhance the system of care serving clients with SCD. The proposal was embraced by the Governor and enacted in the FY 2022 budget appropriation. By FY 2023, 578 adults with SCD have been enrolled with CSHCS. The program continues to implement outreach strategies to reach adults who can benefit from the CSHCS eligibility expansion, while also partnering with colleagues in LEGD to enhance clinical capacity to serve individuals with SCD. In addition, CSHCS is implementing strategies to expand the CMDS clinic model to include adult clinics caring for patients with SCD. Since FY 2022, six CMDS clinics have been added with the hematology/oncology specialty type. Additionally, in FY 2023, the CSHCS transition specialist started working with LEGD and one clinic site to develop toolkits for transition programs to improve the transition to adulthood for SCD patients.
Improved access to respite care for families with CSHCN was identified as a need in the 2020 Needs Assessment. According to the 2019-2020 National Survey of Children’s Health, parents/caregivers of children with special health care needs in Michigan are five times more likely to have left a job, requested a leave of absence, or reduced their work hours due to the stress of their child’s health or health conditions. In response, CSHCS engaged with Partners for Children which completed a survey of 15 states to identify respite gaps and reached out to the Catalyst Center for additional evidence to support a policy change for CSHCS respite. CSHCS convened an internal workgroup with representation from Program Review Division, CSHCS, Office of Medical Affairs, and other partners to review and revise existing CSHCS respite policy. The committee has identified eligibility criteria and is in the process of estimating the population that would benefit from this policy change.
In FY 2023, MDHHS utilized American Rescue Plan Fiscal Recovery Funds to issue relief grants for family caregivers who provided continuous direct care support for a family member during the Public Health Emergency. CSHCS utilized claims data to identify families who met eligibility criteria between March 1, 2020, and May 11, 2023. The grant was provided to families to reimburse a caregiver of their choice for respite services or to help them afford a form of “relief or respite” that meets their needs. Approximately 3,000 CSHCS beneficiaries received a one-time payment of $2,840.
[[1]] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy from any cause related to or aggravated by the pregnancy or its management. Data source: Maternal Deaths in Michigan, 2016-2020 Data Update. MDHHS. Michigan Maternal Mortality Surveillance Program.
[[2]] Includes maternal deaths while pregnant or within 1 year of the end of a pregnancy due to a cause unrelated to pregnancy.
To Top